A number of provisions in the existing Anti-Corruption Commission Act 2004 and loopholes in them make the graft-busting body weak, often resulting in dropping of charges against accused persons, observe former ACC officials and anti-graft campaigners.
A bill to amend the act and strengthen the ACC was placed in parliament on January 28, 2011 for immediate passage. Parliament also sent it to the parliamentary standing committee on the law ministry for consideration, but it is yet to be passed.
Former and serving officials of the commission and rights organisations say passing the amended law will be time-befitting if the government really wants to fight corruption.
The Radar Purchase Graft Case against military dictator HM Ershad has been on trial for more than 20 years. The case – currently awaiting judgement – was filed by the now defunct Anti-Corruption Bureau on May 4, 1992.
Ershad, along with four others, allegedly bought radars from the USA, although those manufactured in France were cheaper. The purchase had allegedly caused Bangladesh a loss of Tk640m.
An ACC official said it was often very hard to prove charges of corruption because people did not want to be witnesses. Collecting evidence in graft cases was also very tough most of the times.
“There are many instances where an accused, after having been punishment by a lower court, secures bail from higher courts. If the new amendment is passed, corruption will be considered as a non-bailable offence,” the official said.
He also pointed out two recent cases where loopholes in the ACC act eventually helped the accused.
The first one is the conditional bail of Jasmine Islam, accused in the Tk30bn Hall-Mark scam, because the bail has been awarded without the gravity of her offence being considering.
The official also pointed out the lengthy process of inquiry into the Tk6bn scam by the BTCL officials. Investigation took almost a year and a half and approval of filing cases took another two months. In the process, some BTCL officials fled the country.
“If corruption is made a non-bail-able offense, the BTCL officials could have been prevented from fleeing the country,” he said.
ACC Chairman M Bodiuzzaman said the commission had been trying to convince the government to pass the amendment bill in the upcoming session of this parliament starting September 12.
“If passed, the act will have a very strong impact on combating corruption. There is only one session left of the current parliament. We have been communicating with the government committees concerned to take necessary steps,” he said.
Former ACC chairman Ghulam Rahman said the commission would not be successful in fighting corruption if the complexity of its legal boundary was not identified.
“The existing act is leading to dropping of charges against many accused because of the loopholes in the commission’s legal structure. The accused can now delay proceedings by appealing and having stay orders from the High Court,” he said.
Official documents of the ACC show that the commission has been able so far to ensure punishment to corrupt people only in a few cases.
If passed, offences under the amended law will become non-bailable. The amendment also proposes five years’ imprisonment for filing false corruption cases, giving the commission independency to file corruption cases against government officials, and making government organisations bound to provide the commission with information it seeks.
“The existing act allows an accused person to seek bail…Investigations also face barriers as many organisations do not provide us with information when needed – we have a timeframe for completing investigations. Sometimes the accused are freed from charges because of lack of concrete evidence,” an ACC investigator told the Dhaka Tribune.
Some 15,000 cases – 8,089 filed by the ACC and 6,919 by the erstwhile Bureau of Anti-Corruption – are awaiting judgment.
Above 3,000 of these cases were stayed by the High Court while 1,331 cases were resolved in court. People were freed of graft charges in 733 cases and verdicts were given against the accused in only 598 cases.
ACC officials, however, could not mention the number of the accused in these cases. No data was found also on the numbers of people who were released and imprisoned.
“We do not have any exact figure on the accused since up to now we have focused only on the cases. The process of building up a complete statistics is, however, in process,” an official told the Dhaka Tribune.
Transparency International Bangladesh Executive Director Iftekharuzzaman alleged that the government was playing hide and seek in passing the amendment bill.
“The bill needs to be passed in the next parliament session, otherwise the Anti-Corruption Commission will face trouble in combating corruption. The government should also first let people know what is in the amendment before passing it.
“Since the revisions of the bill were not disclosed to public, we are doubtful about its effectiveness,” he said.
Asked why the bill has not been passed yet, Chairman of the parliamentary standing committee on the law ministry Fazle Rabbi Mia said they had already endorsed the bill and it was now awaiting the approval of the finance ministry and Cabinet Division.