The main roads through Dhaka’s industrial belt are flooded with colour. Vibrant mandarin scarves flutter in the dusty breeze, billowing against green and fuchsia salwar kameez. A sea of people shuffle along on plastic flip-flops, the crowd thick with young faces packed ten across and hundreds deep. Some are smiling, some are sullen and most are women. They walk briskly past rows of tea stalls and scrap metal hawkers on their way home, into the sprawling slums that grow like the ubiquitous purple hyacinth around the factories. The crowd flows like a swollen river along the side of the road, the sheer number of bodies bringing traffic to a halt.
A natural advantage
This mass of human vitality is just a fraction of Bangladesh’s garment workforce; a few of the more than 3m who knitted, dyed, washed, sewed, ironed, and packaged close to $20bn worth of clothes last year. Bangladesh is well on its way towards industrial development. Like many of its Asian counterparts, the first stage of this transition has taken the form of explosive growth in light manufacturing industries. Bangladeshi industry has a substantial competitive advantage over most countries in the world: The proportion of people at or below working age is extremely high, with close to 70% of the population under 35 years old. This means that a large portion of the population can or will soon be able to participate productively in the economy. This characteristic is often referred to as the “demographic dividend,” which, when combined with low costs of living and a high population density, yields very low labour costs. This youth bulge has been the most significant driver of business to Bangladesh’s ready-made garment (RMG) sector, which is the largest and fastest growing manufacturing industry in Bangladesh and the second largest exporter of garments in the world.
One of the major effects of the “demographic dividend” has been a 6% annual GDP growth over the last decade, which has coincided with plummeting birth and mortality rates, ballooning school enrollment, rising life expectancy and per capita income. However, most of this new found wealth has been accumulated by a small group of people. These “masters of industry,” as well as the central government, have made few investments in the physical and human capital needed to sustain such a high level of growth, allowing millions of labourers to continue to toil inefficiently and unsafely for $0.22 an hour.
Running in circles
In order to secure an economic future in the face of falling birth rates and a diminishing “demographic dividend,” the Bangladeshi economy — and the garment sector in particular — must make a transition to manufacturing more complex and higher value goods. This will require a more skilled and reliable labour force in addition to improved physical infrastructure like electricity, roads, and, as was made tragically clear in a massive factory fire in November 2012 and the collapse in April 2013, the factory facilities themselves. These changes will require reinvestment of the profits from the “demographic dividend,” a necessary step that will also likely increase the cost of labour incrementally over time.
It is important to realise that the cost of labour will increase even if no investments are made, as annual inflation is close to 10%. If factory owners, the central government, and international stakeholders fail to invest in the garment industry, it will continue to grow and be profitable for perhaps another decade. After that, the cost of labour will be too high to justify manufacturing simple and low quality goods. Without investing in workers’ skills and the basic infrastructure needed to move up the value chain, the youth bulge will become an economic liability — an old, skill-less, savings-less, work force whose earnings and standard of living won’t rise with inflation. Their children, who could be part of the most equitable and wealthy generation in the history of the country, will be much less likely to join the ranks of the middle class and more likely to toil in the same industries, producing the same low-quality goods as their parents. That is, of course, only if international buyers and manufacturers of low quality garments have not already made their inevitable transition to new low-wage frontiers in Africa.
Making the leap
How, then, to most quickly, effectively, and realistically go about investing in a safer, more efficient garment sector?
First, members of the various industry groups, including the Garments Manufacturers and Exporters Associate (BGMEA) and Knitwear Manufacturers and Exporters Association (BKMEA), must insist on the establishment and enforcement of a “no poaching” or “first right of refusal” policy for employees seeking to migrate factories. According to industry experts, a major determinant of low efficiency and subsequent unwillingness of factories to upgrade facilities and train workers are extraordinarily high rates of worker migration — ranging from a low of 10% turnover in an average month to more than 50% during two month-long religious festivals. Human resource officers at most factories recruit and hire enough workers each year to fill their roles more than twice over. Of course, there are several reasons that workers migrate — if their family moves or is displaced, if they get married, or if they have a conflict with coworkers or management, to name a few. However, an offer of a higher salary is the most cited reason by workers and employers alike for migration. Some workers will leave the factory where they work for as little as $2 more per month, resulting in a poaching war between neighbouring factories in the industrial zone. This in turn lowers efficiencies by forcing factories to constantly hire and train new workers, making it less likely that factories will invest and risk “losing” their investment to a competing firm.
This view is obviously shortsighted, as a trained worker benefits the industry as a whole if not directly the factory that trained her or him. It is, however, an understandable position. By forcing factories to be transparent in their efforts to lure away employees by offering higher salaries, the workers’ current employers will have the opportunity to match or beat the offer of the poaching factory. Of course, workers themselves can choose whether to leave or not, but under a “no poach” policy they will be able to actively negotiate their compensation. A factory that has a worker poached without first having the opportunity to match or beat the new offer could file a complaint with the industry body, who would issue stiff cash or tax penalties.
Encouraging loyalty
Another concrete modification that could be made to current labour-factory relations is the introduction of additional non-salary compensation. These funds would be held in escrow and released as needed for healthcare and emergencies or upon completion of certain tenure or productivity targets. The use of direct deposits into mobile banking accounts will facilitate this process as well as incentivise workers to save a portion of their monthly salary. Factories could give workers the option to use these additional conditional payments towards improving their home, schooling their children, or saving for retirement, for example. While some factories have experimented with productivity- and attendance-based bonuses, none have introduced a formal benefits package that incentivises long-term skills accumulation and factory loyalty.
As long as a worker complies with the terms of his or her contract, they would receive in full the money or assets set aside for them each month at the end of their contract. However, if a worker violated his or her contract by leaving the factory early, performing poorly, or providing cause for dismissal, only a portion of those additional funds would be released. There would be, of course, a variety of exceptions for health, family emergencies, and extenuating circumstances. The implementation of these reforms, as well as fixed pay raises linked to targets for tenure, attendance, and productivity can help change factory culture from one based on short-term gains by management and workers alike to one focused on building the physical and human capital necessary for the long term success of the firm, industry, and country as a whole.
If not implemented universally, the two aforementioned solutions actually risk plunging those workers at non-participating factories into “dark pools” of labour where wages, benefits, and working conditions are similar or much worse than they are currently. There are more than 5,500 garment factories in Bangladesh, with little plausible state oversight over business and labour practices. Much of the regulatory responsibility has been taken on by international manufacturers who, in many cases, do an admirable job evaluating factories from which they source and insisting on the improvement of conditions when they are found to be lacking. Indeed, firms are far more likely to listen to their buyers than to international NGOs or government auditors.
Essential oversight
It is widely understood that most of the human and labour rights violations take place in factories that do not have direct relationships with international brands, but instead work on “sub-contracts” from firms manufacturing goods for all of the worlds’ largest brands. In some cases, contracting and sub-contracting firms build their businesses on this relationship. A direct contracting firm might invest in a safe, clean, and well-organised factory and pay good wages to its workers in order to secure large orders from an international buyer—only to increase their profit margin by farming out work to much cheaper firms who don’t have to comply with international standards. In other cases, direct contracting firms have no interest in producing garments anywhere but their own socially complaint factory as they do not want to jeopardise the quality of their garments or their relationship with the buyer. Unfortunately, with an increase in general strikes that prevent the movement of workers, raw materials, and finished goods, firms face a tremendous amount of pressure to fulfill their orders on time. The only way to do so is to sub-contract, despite violating the “no sub-contracting” clause often stipulated by buyers. It is worth noting that many of the garments produced in the Tazreen factory that burned down and the Rana Plaza factories that collapsed were on sub-contract from other firms.
The first step to eliminating poor working conditions in subcontracting firms is rather counterintuitive: International brands must acknowledge the economic necessity of sub-contracting and allow firms to do so when necessary. Then, and only then, could it be possible to establish the “transferability” of social compliance responsibilities from firms who take orders directly from international buyers to firms do “sub-contracting” work. Manufacturers that sub-contract would have to report the location and nature of this activity on a regular basis and be held responsible for the working conditions in those factories. It is only by bringing the backwards and dangerous practices of sub-contracting factories into the view of international buyers (and consumers) that the industry can hope to begin to regulate it.
The solutions presented here are by no means comprehensive, a panacea, or easy to implement. As Sir Fazle Hasan Abed, the founder of BRAC, the world’s largest and arguably most successful NGO, argued in hisOp-Ed in the New York Times on April 29, there is much left to be done by all parties. Labour must organize itself and begin to collectively bargain, the government must greatly fortify its monitoring of work conditions and mercilessly root out the widespread corruption between businessmen and politicians, and manufacturers and international buyers must be willing to sacrifice short-term profits to make investments in safety, training, and infrastructure that will secure a future for manufacturing in Bangladesh. The policies I propose are just the tip of the iceberg—what is crucial is that that concrete steps are taken immediately to ensure that the benefits of Bangladesh’s “demographic dividend” are felt by future generations.