The government’s decision to reopen offices and resume public transport service has been stirring up debate on whether Bangladesh is ready to totally lift its lockdown.
Against this backdrop, the country has seen an upward trend in Covid-19 cases and deaths over the last few days.
However, a recently published predictive model suggests that enforcing intermittent lockdowns in phases could save the economy and lower the Covid-19 death rate significantly.
According to this model, Covid-19 death and transmission rate could be kept at bay, if intermittent cycles of suppression and relaxation measures are taken.
This intermittent lockdown could reduce Covid-19 casualty by 99.01% and the number of new cases by 99.61%, if intermittent cycles of 50-day suppression and 30-day relaxation measures are imposed.
The academic paper, “Dynamic Interventions to Control Covid-19 pandemic: A multivariate prediction modelling study comparing 16 worldwide countries” published the findings in a European Journal of Epidemiology in May.
According to the model, a 50-day mitigation or suppression after a 30-day relaxation could reduce the transmission rate. However, this strategy would not be effective if the healthcare system is not prepared to treat critical Covid-19 patients who need hospital care.

Suppression, mitigation, or no intervention?
According to the study, mitigation by definition is done by isolating suspected cases and their households, and social distancing the elderly and people at higher risk of serious illness.
Suppression is stricter and done by ensuring social distancing for the entire population over a longer time period, closing educational institutes and offices.
If intermittent cycles of suppression and relaxation are followed, the number of new infections per day during the peak could be kept to 36,597 and the number of total deaths over 18 months can be kept to 4908.
However, if the intermittent cycles of mitigation and relaxation are followed, a much higher number of new infections per day during the peak could be 2,427,104, and the number of deaths over 18 months could be as high as 226,700.
The study also looked at what might happen if the government lifts the lockdown completely and does not intervene at all.
If the authorities do not intervene, Bangladesh may see 9,270,170 new infections per day at the peak and a total of 495,420 deaths over 18 months.
According to another research conducted by UK’s Imperial College and published at the end of March, social distancing needs to be maintained for 27% to 48% of the country’s population in a mitigation strategy, particularly for the elderly and those who are vulnerable.
On the other hand, the suppression strategy requires social distancing 75% of the entire population.
The paper concludes: “As a policy option, efficient implementation of dynamic suppression interventions worldwide, therefore, would help prevent critical care overload and deaths, and gain time to develop preventive and clinical measures, and reduce economic hardship globally.”

Where Bangladesh stands
Until June 3, Bangladesh recorded 55,140 Covid-19 cases and 746 deaths from the deadly virus since March 8, when the first three cases were reported.
The government took a few initiatives to control the virus transmission such as announcing a general ‘holiday’ till May 30, suspending app-based ride-sharing services, locking down a few areas, shutting down education institutions, and so on.
However, the measures taken by the government were widely criticized when people continued flouting the health guidelines.
The health authorities in Bangladesh developed health guidelines for the citizens in May.
The guideline has categorized different sections including health guidelines for office spaces, public transports, shopping malls, restaurants, religious places, and other public places.
However, the real challenge is to have citizens and organizations follow these guidelines religiously.
The models also predicted that cycles of a 50-day mitigation intervention followed by a 30-day relaxation would likely reduce the effective reproduction number R to 0.8 in all countries.
The number R is the number of people that one infected person will pass the virus on to, on average.
Currently, the reproduction number in Bangladesh is 1.19. The number of cases increases exponentially if the reproductive number is more than 1.
The basic reproduction number (R0) is 2.2 for no intervention, 0.8 for dynamic mitigation interventions, and 0.5 for dynamic suppression interventions.

What experts are saying
At a recent webinar hosted by Dhaka Tribune, Rumi Ahmed Khan, associate professor of UCF College of Medicine in the US, pointed out that lockdown cannot work effectively to control Covid-19 transmission if the authorities do not work on other measures like ramping up testing capacity, enhancing the healthcare system, and making good policies.
"Lockdown is one piece of a puzzle. It can work effectively if other pieces of the puzzle are in place. If we keep pushing the lockdown, we will only delay the surge. We would not really make anything tangible to make the curve flat," he said.
The general holiday along with other measures might buy the government some time to enhance the healthcare system to prepare for treating Covid-19 positive patients who need hospital care.
The healthcare system was widely criticized during the pandemic for refusing patients who needed other non-Covid-19 medical care, for running a low number of tests to detect Covid-19, and making people wait too long to get tested and so on.
As for ventilators, key equipment to treat critical Covid-19 patients, Bangladesh is still facing a huge shortage of ventilators, as the government could not import a single one of the devices in the last 12 weeks of coronavirus infection.
There are only 1,267 ventilators — 520 at state-run hospitals and 737 at private hospitals — attached to ICUs for the total population of the country.
The government has only 399 dedicated ICU beds with ventilators for treatment of critical Covid-19 patients against a population size of 161.4 million people.
Even if the government enforces lockdown periodically, they must enhance healthcare facilities and set up ICUs with ventilator facilities to get desired results.
Abbas Bhuiya, an independent Bangladeshi health and population researcher, and Daniel Reidpath of the International Centre for Diarrhoeal Disease Research, Bangladesh authored the paper with others.
Researchers have developed this multivariate prediction model using available age structure data of 16 different countries selected from different geographical regions: The Netherlands, Belgium, Chile, Colombia, Mexico, South Africa, Nigeria, Ethiopia, Tanzania, Uganda, India, Bangladesh, Pakistan, Sri Lanka, Yemen, and Australia.