The mooting that wins the heart

Moot is a shadow court. It gives a law student the taste of real-life lawyering experience. In that sense, a mooter is a lawyer in the making. 

But mooting is not to be confused with trial advocacy. The latter delves into both questions of law and fact, while the former primarily focuses on the question of law and its interpretation. 

The legal curricula in Bangladesh usually do not have mooting components; however, they encourage the same through various competitions. 

One such competition is the ELCOP Constitutional Law Moot Court Competition named after M Shah Alam, a legendary law professor in Bangladesh. 

Prof Alam, who died last year, was the founder dean of Chittagong University Law and served in the Law Commission of Bangladesh twice. 

The second edition of the competition was held virtually on June 24-27. 

As one of the participants, I familiarized myself with some important tenets of moot lawyering, and would like to share that experience here.  

Dhaka University team with their awards from the event Courtesy

Twenty-Six law schools made their written submissions (i.e., memorials) to ELCOP experts, who selected 16 teams for the oral encounter in the competition. 

The teams researched on a fictitious fact, consulted the relevant law, analyzed them in line with the given fact, and then prepared memorials. 

This was the stage where the student-lawyers learn to marshal the facts and relate the relevant law and authoritative work to support their claims. 

The fact this year very candidly posed a problem on the dichotomy between the right to religion and freedom of expression. 

Although imaginary, the issues resembled the questions of the state's authority to regulate the citizens' freedom of expression, and the much-talked-about edge of hurting religious feelings through a presentation on social media that we discover in a real miasmic social milieu. 

The petitioners represented the aggrieved individuals to challenge a digital law that allegedly unreasonably curbed the right to free speech and the prosecution of two people under said law, the respondents (i.e., the state) had to defend their actions. 

The competing teams submitted memorials both for and against the case, and assumed the roles of either the petitioner or the respondent at various follow-up stages of the competition. 

Sixteen teams fought fiercely to get into the quarter-final and semi-final rounds, after they were adjudicated and evaluated by the judges. 

The semi-finalists were Dhaka University, Brac University, Eastern University, and the University of Asia Pacific. 

As the competition progressed, the legal battle became more intense. Unlike a debate competition, the young legal minds had to respond to the queries posed by the bench judges and defend the party they represented. 

It was a dream come true to appear before the experts of different standing who were the judges in the competition. They were not only real court judges, but also renowned lawyers, law professors, and journalists from home and abroad. 

The  photo shows a part of the judges team joining the event virtually Courtesy 

In a way, the moot court competition established a bridge between the new generation of moot lawyers and legal experts. 

The judges included Justice Ashraful Kamal, Justice Nizamul Huq, Barrister Tania Amir, Barrister Tanjibul Alam, Dhaka Tribune Editor Zafar Sobhan, Prof Thio Li-Ann, Prof Biswajit Chanda, Prof Abdullah Al Faruque, senior journalist Saleem Samad, Dr Faustina Pereira, advocate Amit Das Gupta, advocate Munzill Murshid, Prof Kaberi Gayen, and Khaled Hamid Chowdhury. 

After an intense battle in the virtual courtroom, the team from Dhaka University emerged as the champion of the tournament, and the team from Brac University became the runners-up. 

Raihan Ferdous from Dhaka University, and I, from Brac University, were awarded the best mooter of the tournament and rebellious lawyer of the final, respectively. 

Dhaka University bagged the best memorial awards for both petitioners and respondents. The team from the Exim Bank Agricultural University of Bangladesh won the spirit of the moot award. 

The competition was inaugurated by Prof Mizanur Rahman, founder and chairman of ELCOP and former chairman of National Human Rights Commission, and advocate AM Amin Uddin, the attorney general of Bangladesh. 

Dr Shahdeen Malik, a prominent jurist of the country, graced the closing ceremony. 

The whole competition was coordinated by a group of student-volunteers from different law schools under the supervision of Barrister Tapas Kanti Baul, executive director of ELCOP, and Dr SM Masum Billah, associate professor of law at Jagannath University in Dhaka. 

Although a virtual moot court is different from a real moot court in many aspects, the organizers excellently managed the smooth running of the competition. 

This competition has surely boosted the confidence of young law students in legal advocacy and helped us learn countless ways of improving our speaking, research and communication skills.

 Tarazi Mohammed Sheikh is a law student at Brac University and the winner of the best mooter of the tournament