The challenges of the EC

The upcoming election has placed the Election Commission (EC) at the centre of attention in the political arena as well as among the public. 

BNP chairperson Khaleda Zia is behind bars after being convicted in the Zia Orphanage Trust graft case, and its Senior Vice Chairman Tarique Rahman has been living abroad for years. Given this, BNP has been demanding fair polls under a neutral government, while the incumbent Awami League seems to be heading into the elections to keep themselves in power.

Hence, the question arises as to whether the Election Commission will be able to hold a free, fair, and acceptable national election in the curr¬ent political scenario, as the neutral image of the electoral body has already been marred by controversies. This is exacerbated by the fact that political parties that are not in power have been claiming the electoral body has failed to maintain a fair process for most of the local government polls in the last five years.

Meanwhile, Awami League leaders have emphasized, on several occasions, that they will extend their full support to the EC in order to hold a free and fair election. 

In the wake of this situation, election experts have said that the Election Commission has to prove itself before the elections. The main problem with the Election Commission is credibility, which they have lost due to their partisan attitude in the local government polls held over the last five years. 

The Election Commission now needs to show some courage in order to regain the trust of the people and political parties, the election experts said—adding that the body must show that it will not be influenced by the government. It will have to identify the problems it faced during the local government polls and learn from them. The vital challenge will be to avoid influences at the field level.

The Election Commission should maintain fairness in the polls even if it means amending the constitution.

Regaining people’s trust

Badiul Alam Majumdar, secretary of Shushashoner Jonno Nagorik (Shujan), said the decision about the Barishal City Corporation (BCC) polls – where allegations of severe irregularities emerged and demands to cancel the polls were raised by the BNP – is an acid test for the Election Commission in the process of regaining the people’s trust.

During that election, held on July 30, ruling party mayoral candidate Serniabat Sadiq Abdullah won by defeating BNP candidate Mujibur Rahman Sarwar. Amid allegations of irregularities, the Election Commission launched a probe and found that vote rigging had taken place at 17 of the polling centres. However, on voting day, the returning officer suspended polls at 16 centres—seven of which the Election Commission probe team found upon investigation, had no irregularities . 

However, one of the election commissioners proposed suspending the entire election.  

Badiul Alam Majumdar said the commission is now thinking of holding the polls according to the constitution. “There is an issue here. The Election Commission’s duty is not to hold polls in line with the constitution; their duty is to hold a perfect election by doing whatever is necessary for that,” he said.

“Even if the constitution itself poses a barrier against a perfect election, the Election Commission is allowed to question it and ask for amendments to it,” he said.

Lack of a caretaker government

Through the scrapping of the caretaker government provision, the heavily-debated fifteenth amendment to the constitution has blocked the path to holding a free and fair election. “The government weaponized a legal framework with the ploy,” Badiul added.

A non-partisan administration during the election was achieved when the caretaker government system was in place.

“As there will be no non-partisan government now, the Election Commission has to undertake the responsibility of being neutral during the polls,” he added.

The first thing the commission must do now is to repel unethical pressure from the government’s side. “They need to have the courage and ethics to stand against any influence, as this will be essential to holding a free and fair election.”

Badiul Alam Majumdar also said the EC should deploy the army during the election in order to ensure a level playing field. They should also scrutinize if any laws have been put in place by the government which could act against holding a fair election—and ask the government to amend those laws.

If the Election Commission feels that it is possible for them to hold a fair election in the current political situation, avoiding external influences, they can announce that and work to ensure that environment, he said.

Participation

“If all parties feel comfortable in taking part in the national polls and fear no outside interference, only then can it be said that the Election Commission is fully prepared to hold a free and fair poll. Thus, the electoral body needs to ensure full participation in the election,” Badiul stated.   

However, Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) KM Nurul Huda recently said that it is not possible for the Election Commission to ensure all parties participate in the next parliamentary election, as political parties have the right to decide whether they will participate or not. The comment drew criticism from many quarters.

Nurul also said they want a free, participatory, fair, and acceptable election—and if the BNP does not join, they risk losing their status as a registered political party.

However, election experts have said that national polls will only be acceptable if all parties participate. Thus, it will be a new experience for the Election Commission to hold the national election under a partisan government with all parties in the race.

Former election commissioner Brig Gen (retd) M Sakhawat Hussain said if all political parties participate in this election, it will be the first contested national polls since the caretaker government system was scrapped—and a new experience for the Election Commission. In the 2014 election, half the candidates were elected uncontested, and law enforcement agencies were able to deal with issues that arose.

This time, the electoral body has to keep in mind that every constituency will be contested by rival political parties, and this has not yet happened in the country under a political-party led government. “If the commission has already reviewed their experience in conducting the 2014 polls, they must have, by now, identified the problems of holding polls under this kind of government.”

Some signs of major challenges to be faced have already been spotted during the city corporation elections, he said. 

“It is now the Election Commission’s duty to find out what changes need to be made to the electoral code of conduct and the Representation of the People Order (RPO) to overcome the challenges.”

Sakhawat added: “There are many instances of free and fair national elections being held under an incumbent government in a number of countries in the world, but these examples will not help unless the Election Commission learns from them.

EC-government dynamics

Asked whether the Election Commission seems ready to hold an acceptable election, the former election commissioner said that the body cannot do so alone. The EC needs to accept help from the government in the form of manpower. “The EC knows they will need to do that, and that the government will cooperate.”

“If a government stays in power for ten years, it gains a certain level of influence. When an election is held under such a government, even if the upper echelons of the government do not want to exercise any influence, the repercussions of their lengthy tenure is automatically felt at the field level.”

“Now, the biggest challenge for the commission is to find out how they will manage to reduce or tackle that influence,” he added.