WB report: MPO policy failed to reap benefit

A recent World Bank report says the government policy to award Monthly Pay Order (MPO) facility to schools to improve the quality of education has largely failed.

There has been no strong impetus for improvement in the schools under MPO system and under-performing schools are hardly penalised, says the report.

The World Bank’s report Seeding Fertile Ground: Education That Works for Bangladesh was released last week.

The report says that political support rather than adherence to quality criteria appears to be more important for the continuation of MPOs.

“In the urban areas a secondary school must have at least 50 students and half of them must pass the terminal public examination. Once a school is recognised for subvention the government is hardly able to enforce the criteria mainly for political reasons,” the report observed.

The MPO system is a subvention that the government provides to secondary school teachers. Earlier the teachers under the MPO system used to draw 50% of the basic salary of a government school teachers in 1980.

But since 2006 they have been given 100% of the basic salary of a government school teacher. At present 98% of the secondary schools are run under the MPO scheme.

Though the system helped to expand secondary education, educationists often raise questions about the accountability of the system.

Teachers often allege that those who deserve are not awarded MPOs but very often undeserving schools are given MPO in exchange for bribe.

In August last year, a probe report found 10 employees of the Directorate of Secondary and Higher Education (DSHE) guilty of illegally awarding Monthly Pay Order (MPO) scheme to 287 teachers of a number of schools and madrasas who were not eligible.

The probe report said 287 teachers could have never been able to get the MPO facility if proper legal process had been followed. The report further said those teachers bribed 10 employees to get the facilities.

Even policy makers often criticise MPO system

On October 6 last year, Finance Minister Abul Maal Abdul Muhith told parliament that the monthly payment order (MPO) for educational institutions had led to slide in the quality of education.

Muhith came up with the anti-MPO statement in response to a question of Awami League lawmaker Abdul Matin Khasru who asked him whether he would release the Tk10b as MPO for 900 teachers.

“Time has come for the government to rethink about the MPO system,” Power and Participation Research Centre Executive Chairman Hossain Zillur Rahman said while speaking at the launching of the World Bank report.

Former Director of Dhaka University’s Institute of Education and Research Siddiqur Rahman also said that in some cases MPO system is misused.

“In some cases, a non government school is built in the name of a late father or mother of a local politician at a place where there is no need of school and the school apply for MPO,” he said.

He, however, said that MPO system is a good tool to support teachers particularly those in the rural areas.

“What government can do is enhance monitoring and set some conditions and be strict that MPO facility is not given without fulfilling those conditions,” Siddiqur, who was a member of the committee that formulated education policy 2010, said.

He said that in MPO system teacher’s salary scale is often upgraded automatically and proposed that it could be done on the basis of assessing performance and a departmental examination.

The World Bank report proposed that one way of enhancing accountability is to publicise the performance of schools, set up conditions necessary for obtaining and retaining MPOs so as to raise public awareness and involvement in using this extremely important resource to support the achievement of learning outcomes.

Education Minister Nurul Islam Nahid told the Dhaka Tribune that government was working to make the MPO system effective.

He admitted that there are some complexities in MPO system though the system is helping to expand secondary education.

“Sometimes eligible institutions might not get MPOs for fund constraint and sometimes institutions that are supposed to get MPOs do not get it,” he said.

“We are trying to make a balance so that the deserving schools can get MPO and schools that are already enjoying the facility can perform to the expected level,” he said.