Free reign for private medical colleges

Although the existing regulations suggest that private medical colleges must submit “annual audit reports” to the health ministry, in practice, none of them do. As a result the ministry or the health directorate do not have any trace of the actual revenues and expenditures of the 54 private medical schools throughout the country.

There are allegations that these med schools, which charge students millions as “development fees,” hardly ever spend any for actual development. Consequently, most of these colleges lack the necessary infrastructure including learning equipment and an adequate number of competent educators.

A number of responsible officials of the health ministry and the Directorate General of Health Services (DGHS), preferring to remain anonymous, told the Dhaka Tribune that none of these colleges submit annual audit reports to them. They said, had these colleges regularly submitted the reports the authorities would have been able to have clear ideas about how much money is being collected from students and how much is actually being allocated as developmental expenditure, like setting up more practical classes, purchasing new equipment, paying the salaries of doctors and staff, and so on.

Other sources said up until a couple of years ago, 15-20% of the med schools used to submit their reports but had stopped doing so recently. The Dhaka Tribune has learnt that the authorities cannot force these colleges to submit the reports because many of them are owned by influential ministers, ruling party lawmakers, and leaders of government-backed doctors’ associations.

According to the Private Medical College Establishment and Management Policy 2011, the private med schools must methodically preserve the records of all the transactions that they had made. Professor Dr ABM Abdul Hannan, director (medical education and health manpower development) of DGHS said he had joined the post about six months ago and none of the colleges had submitted their reports since. The health ministry, however, could not tell whether any of these colleges had presented their reports.

The Dhaka Tribune has learnt that these private schools charge students between Tk1.5m-Tk2.5m as development fees when the students enrol, while also charging them many hundreds of thousands more during different periods of their academic tenure on various purposes.

There are allegations that the only thing these colleges care about is how quickly they can become rich. Most of the college authorities are very reluctant in spending money for even the most basic infrastructural development. The college authorities are also reportedly very enthusiastic about increasing the number of seats without actually expanding the facilities to accommodate the increased number of students. There are also allegations against some owners that they invest the money abroad instead of spending them for development.

Seeking anonymity, the guardians of a number of students said the government should monitor what these colleges are doing. They said, apart from a few, most of these colleges do not have the most basic level of teaching and learning facilities despite charging millions to students. Also seeking anonymity, a number of senior specialist doctors told the Dhaka Tribune, with resentment, that almost none of these colleges have ever managed to graduate good and competent doctors. They also said the graduates of these private schools were falling behind in competition in the Bangladesh Civil Service examinations as well.

Professor Dr Shah Mohammad Selim, secretary general of the Bangladesh Private Medical College Association, claimed that all the colleges methodically and regularly prepare the audit reports. But due to a lack of initiative and interest from the health ministry, sometimes they do not submit the reports.

DGHS Director General Professor Dr Khondaker Md Shefyetullah told the Dhaka Tribune that authorities were going to take stern actions to ensure that the private med schools duly submitted their audit reports.