Wearing a white school dress, a heavy bag slung over his shoulder, five-year-old pre-schooler Tasnimul Hasan emerges from class with a pale face. The reason for his bad mood is revealed when his mother asks to show his report card.
Seeing the card, Sayeeda Yasmin begins scolding her son for his grades, which are not up to her expectations.
Sayeeda tells our correspondent she is worried about her son’s future, since he is not getting good grades. “If children do not learn the basics in this age, they will suffer their whole lives,” she says.
Educationists working on pre-schooling, however, think this is a wrong idea and could in fact be harmful to the children in the long term.
Siddiqur Rahman, a professor at Dhaka University’s Institute of Education and Research (IER), says the pre-primary education that Bangladesh’s schools are running is faulty in design and may harm the children.
“The idea of pre-school is that children will learn by playing and other entertaining activities so that they become interested in reading and learning,” he said.
What schools in Bangladesh are doing will make children afraid of studying, he says. “There might be long term problems and there is also a risk that children will drop out of schools,” he says.
Sayeeda says Tasnim has to read 12 books and has to take six to seven exams on these subjects. Speaking to a number of guardians, our correspondent found that most schools are putting a huge workload on their pre-schoolers.
Most guardians however, were appreciative, saying the extra pressure would help them have excellent careers in the future.
“I could not succeed in life as I did not have the pre-schooling that my children having now,” said Mokarram Hossain, whose child goes to a pre-school in Uttara.
He thinks that going through a big syllabus at this age will not have any bad effects on children.
Primary and mass education ministry’s framework for pre-primary created in 2008 defines pre-primary education as developmental and educational support provided to children of three to six years in order to ensure the child’s right to protection, care, survival and preparation for school education through play, amusement and introduction to literacy and numeracy, irrespective of the child’s physical, mental and social status.
But most of the country’s schools are not following this guideline. Directorate of Primary Education says there are 78,685 primary level educational institutions in the country. Most of them have pre-schools. There are also 10,537 kindergarten schools in the country, most of which also have pre-schools. In many schools the teachers are not trained on pre-schooling.
Manzoor Ahmed, senior adviser at the Brac University’s Institute of Educational Development, said, “Preparing young children for primary education through preschool programmes is critical for equity in participation and performance in primary education. The intended result can be achieved only when minimum quality standards can be ensured in the programmes.”
Professor Nazrul Islam from Dhaka University’s psychology department says overburdening children will have negative impact on their minds. “In Bangladesh, admission test for class one is tougher than Bangladesh Civil Service exams. This is ridiculous,” he said.
Due to this extreme pressure children are losing interest in studies, Islam says.
“Study means a torture to children for extreme pressure in the early childhood,” he says. He thinks that this faulty pre-schooling will have serious impact on the mental development of children.
“There is a limit on how much a child’s brain can take. When we put extra pressure on them, they simply lose interest in studies,” he says.
Children in Bangladesh have to read an abnormally high number of books compared to children in the US or other developed countries, Islam says.