‘Upazila governance ineffective’

After its restoration in 1998 the first government baseline survey on upazila governance in its immediate-past term shows dismal performance of the mid-tier local body.

At least 60% of the elected representatives of the local government body term the upazila council – a body created to ensure development at the grassroots through participation of local people instead of bureaucracy-led local administration – ineffective.

An upazila council consists of an elected chairman, a vice-chairman and a vice-chairwoman and all elected chairmen of the union councils in that upazila. The upazila nirbahi officer (UNO), an administration service officer, is the member secretary of the council.

The upazila governance project under the local government ministry carried out a study on 42 upazilas in seven divisions has examined the performance of the local government body for four years since the upazila polls in 2009.

The UN Development Programme funded the study conducted by a group of researchers led by Monzur Hossain, a research fellow of the Bangladesh Institute of Development Studies.

In line with the Upazila Act 1998, the government put over 17 departments under upazila council but department officials hardly listen to the elected representatives, according to the survey.

The study also says local MPs or their representatives and the UNO control all activities at upazila level.

“This [the study finding] is true. Why will the department officials listen to us? We have not been given the financial and administrative authority over the council,” Harunur Rashid Hawlader, a leader of the association of the upazila chairmen, told the Dhaka Tribune.

He said the UNO was the administrative chief of the officials of those departments, not upazila chairmen. The association has several times demanded administrative and financial authorities but the government has not agreed.

The study finds that local level officials of the departments have “conservative mind-set or ego of working under democratically elected local level representatives, which is not consistent with the constitutional mandate.”

It says the department officials see a clear improvement in public service delivery through increasing accountability and transparency but they are also worried about political interference that might plague the departments with corruption.

Dr Hossain Zillur Rahman who carried out several studies on local government told the Dhaka Tribune that the bureaucrats should not be blamed solely for the non-functioning of the upazila council. “The local MPs through their agents control everything; the national leaders interfere in the activities of the local leaders,” he said.

Rahmat Ali MP, a former state minister for local government and former chairman of the parliamentary standing committee on local government, said lawmakers’ interference was one of the causes of dysfunctional upazila councils.

“But many of the upazila chairmen have tainted careers; there should be some check-and-balance in giving authority to the upazila chairmen,” he said.

According to the study, none of the upazila councils have had adopted any measure to curb corruption in the councils.

The people perception about the development initiatives is also lacklustre, says the study adding that around 90% of voters know nothing about the annual development plan of the upazila. Again, it said, over 99% of the people responded that they had no idea about the project selection by the upazila councils.

Former military ruler HM Ershad created upazila system promulgating an ordinance in early 1980s after he usurped power. After his ouster through street agitation in 1990, the next BNP-led government in 1991 annulled the upazila system.

The Awami League in the seventh parliament (1996-2001) enacted a law to revive the upazila council but the polls did not take place. Assuming office in January 2009 it arranged the upazila polls the same year.

The government amended the law twice but the upazila council remained ineffective in achieving its desired role.