Subhan’s brutality stuns tribunal

The brutality of Abdus Subhan, now the nayeb-e-ameer of Jamaat-e-Islami, on Bengali Muslims and non-combatant civilians of his own locality during the birth of the nation stunned the tribunal.

“We fail to understand how the accused, Subhan, being a Bengali Muslim, actively aided, abetted, and facilitated the commission of such crimes with extreme cruelty, against the non-combatant civilians of his own locality. Does this match with humanity?” the International Crimes Tribunal-2, that handed down the death sentence, said in the verdict yesterday. 

“The accused Maulana Abdus Subhan was the acting ameer of Pabna district Jamaat, an Islamist political party. That is to say, he was a leadership position of Jamaat in 1971, and his position bespeaks that he had to work in the spirit and philosophy of Islam.”

“But did he do that? No, rather by discarding the holy spirit of Islam, he opted to become a man of extreme notoriety around the Pabna locality, as he consciously and actively aided, abetted, assisted, and substantially facilitated the Pakistani occupation army in committing atrocious, horrific acts constituting the offence of murder, large-scale killing, and massive destruction.”

The role of the accused thus impels the conclusion that Jamaat, to which the accused Subhan belonged, was a criminal organisation, the tribunal said. 

According to charge number one, which earned him a death sentence, on April 17, 1971 before Asr prayers, Subhan accompanied by his accomplices, entering Iswardi Central Jame Masjid [mosque],in execution of a plan, apprehended Moazzem Hossain who had taken shelter there. 

They dragged him forcibly to Iswardi Coal Depot where he was indiscriminately stabbed to death.

The next morning, Subhan accompanied by Khoda Bakhsh and Biharis again arrived at the mosque to apprehend Awami League supporter Motaleb Khan and his son Nazmul Huq Khan and similarly forcibly took them to Iswardi Coal Deport where the accused caused their death by inflicting knife and sword blows. 

In this instance, Subhan, Khoda Bakhsh, and his Bihari accomplices killed around 20 unarmed Awami League supporters within seven days at the Iswardi Coal Deport.

Charge 4, which has been proved beyond doubt, claimed on the afternoon of April 11, 1971, a group of the Pakistani army made their station at Iswardi Airport and in places around it. The accused Subhan and his accomplices, Khoda Bakhsh and the Biharis, designed a plan with them [the army] to annihilate all listed pro-liberation supporters, freedom fighters, and members of the Hindu community. 

And accordingly, under the accused’s leadership, on May 2, 1971 after Fazr prayers, the group of Khoda Bakhsh Khan, local Biharis, and army men launched an attack on the village of Shahpur, where the soldiers gunned down and killed Chand Ali Pramanik, Akhtar Pramanik, Anar Pramanik, and Hamejuddin Pramanik. 

In conjunction with this attack, they also killed Rajob Ali Biswas and Shamsul Huq, the residents of the same village, around 7am. 

On the same day, the group of attackers looted valuables from 10-15 houses, including that of Chand Ali Pramanik, Principal Toyob Hossain, and Rahman Sarder and then set the houses on fire.

Charge number 6, that also earned him a death penalty stated, on May 12, 1971. a group of 300 members of the Pakistani army, accompanied by the accused Moulana Abdus Subhan, the acting Ameer of Pabna district Jamaat and vice-president of Pabna district peace committee, launched attacks on a Bangalee national group and Hindu religious group in Momrajpur, Kuripara, Tarabaria, Fokitpur, Satbaria, Kandarpur, Sindurpur, Nishchintapur, Gupinpur, Harirampur, Shyamnagar, Narohati, Singhanagar and Bhatpara, under police station Sujanagar district in Pabna, and abducted 400 leaders and workers of the Awami League, supporters of the war of liberation, and members of the Hindu community, and killed them. 

In conjunction with the attack, the perpetrators burned down and plundered several houses. Therefore, the accused has been charged for abetting and facilitating commission of the offences of murder as crimes against humanity and also for the offence of genocide.

The son of Sheikh Naimuddin and Nurani Begum of Tailakundi village in Sujanagar upazila of Pabna, Subhan was the general secretary of the peace committee, a collaborating force of the Pakistani occupation army, in Pabna in 1971, according to the prosecution. Later, he was made vice-president of the committee.

He was the founding ameer of Jamaat-e-Islami’s Pabna unit and a Majlish-e-Sura member of the party’s central unit during the war, said the prosecution.

Subhan was elected unopposed a member of the National Assembly of Pakistan in 1971. He fled to Pakistan when the war was nearing its end. He rejoined politics after the assassination of Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman in 1975.

He was elected lawmaker from Jamaat in 1996 and 2001, according to a defence counsel.