Surgery table blunder costs patient his kidney

A doctor has allegedly removed the right kidney, instead of the stones in it, from a patient at the Uttara Adhunik College Hospital in the capital.

The physician Sabbir Khan called it just an accident.

A case was filed with the Western Uttara police station by patient Babul Sarkar’s brother-in-law Momen Sarkar, accusing the hospital chairman, director and the doctor who operated on him.

Babul, who hails from the Kaliganj upazila in Gazipur, is related to Momen by marriage with the latter’s sister. He was admitted to the hospital with lower back pains after consultation with the Department of Urology Chairman Sabbir Khan.

After an x-ray and ultra-sonogram had been done, Babul was diagnosed with stones in the kidney after which the doctor told them that it would be a minor laser operation and cost Tk20 thousand only, he said.

“Since we permitted an operation on him, he was taken to the theatre around 11:30am on November 26. After the operation, we were told that his kidney had been removed,” Momen said.

“We were not informed that his kidney would be removed.  If so, why was the kidney removed?” he questioned, adding that his sister fainted as soon as she heard about the removal of Babul’s kidney.

Babul Sarker’s wife Suraiya echoed him in saying: “We were informed about this only after the kidney was removed. My husband still does not know about the kidney removal. He would break down getting to know this.”

When the accused, doctor Sabbir was questioned, he said: “It was just an accident.” and claimed that the patient’s wife had been informed beforehand that it might require the removal of the kidney during the operation.” He however did not explain why it was an accident.

When contacted, hospital Director Shahjahan Biswas told the Dhaka Tribune that they already formed a three-member committee to investigate this on December 1 after receiving a written complaint. 

“The committee has been asked to submit their report within three days. After receiving the report, we would know what had actually happened,” he said.