Tribunal slams prosecution for poor performance

The International Crimes Tribunal 1 yesterday halted the hearing on charge framing for one month in the case against fugitive suspect Syed Hassan Ali alias Hachhen Ali, a razakar commander from Kishoreganj.

“You are taking this case lightly as the accused is absconding,” the tribunal told the prosecution. Like the prosecution, the defence side was also not prepared for the hearing.

Not only yesterday, the same tribunal expressed discontent over the informal attitude of the designated prosecutor of this case, Abul Kalam, on August 5. It also slammed the prosecution on June 30 for not handling the cases properly.

The tribunal yesterday came down hard on prosecutor Mohammad Ali, who stood on behalf of Abul Kalam, since he was not prepared well enough.

In the middle of his hearing, Ali said they did not have enough document for evidence but they think they will able to prove the case through oral evidence.

The tribunal stopped him and said: “You have to answer why you submitted these newspaper clippings and what is the relevance of these papers with the case.”

It also said the investigation had not been done sincerely and this is why the irrelevant evidence was placed before the court.

Referring to the recent verdict of Delawar Hossain Sayedee case, the tribunal said: “In that case, only one document, which is related with the murder of Ibrahim Kutti, changed the direction of the case.”

The tribunal said: “The papers you submitted were not placed properly...We cannot say too much, the media writes about you every day.”

The three-member tribunal, led by Justice M Enayetur Rahim, said mentioning the chief prosecutor: “Whenever your team goes investigates, please ensure that they collect the books written by local witnesses and writers. There is enough evidence in the field.”

Moreover, state-appointed defence counsel Abdus Sukkur placed in his discharge petition that the prosecution had submitted document of a case which was filed against Hassan Ali on March 26, 1972 without mentioning further development about the case.

When the tribunal asked the prosecutor about it, they failed to give an answer. Even the investigation officer, Hari Devnath, who was present at court, could not answer.

Then tribunal then adjourned the case until October 22 saying: “Please, come properly prepared and satisfy us.”

Before that, prosecutor Ali claimed that they had enough evidence to prove the six charges brought against the accused.

The tribunal took the charges into cognisance on September 15.