The Dhaka Medical College Hospital authority Wednesday distributed cheques totalling Tk110m among para-clinical staff as a “user fee commission” a move that the clinical staff claim was a violation of a Supreme Court stay order.
The members of the DMCH clinical staff alleged that soon after office opening hours Wednesday, authorities, in what they claim was “suspicious haste,” handed over the cheques to the departmental heads of Radiology and Imaging, Radiotherapy, Clinical Pathology, Nephrology, and other para-clinical divisions.
Staff also alleged that the move was a clear violation of a Supreme Court (SC) order issued on August 20 staying the disbursement of any such payments to para-clinical staff.
Professor Dr Billal Alam from the DMCH Medicine Department, a clinical wing, told the Dhaka Tribune that the SC on August 20 stayed the July 23 HC judgement.
But the hospital authorities, despite being informed about the SC order, hurriedly distributed the cheques Wednesday.
DMCH authorities, however, claimed that they were not aware of any such SC order.
In fact, they said the money was distributed in accordance with a High Court (HC) directive issued on July 23 that asked the authorities concerned to distribute the money within a month of the issuance of the order.
Refusing to accept any of the allegations, DMCH Deputy Director Dr Musfiqur Rahman said the money was distributed Wednesday in order to avoid violation of the HC order.
He also said there were clear directives from the health ministry about distributing the money among the para-clinical staff following previous arrangements.
However, the Dhaka Tribune got a hold of a document showing that Prof Billal Alam and others filed a civil petition for leave in order to appeal with the Appellate Division to stay the high court order.
The document also claimed that the Appellate Division had actually issued an order staying the July 23 HC judgement.
The Dhaka Tribune has also got its hands on the photocopy of a certified copy of an Appellate Division order that had stayed the operation of the HC judgement until September 26 that is, till the petition came up for hearing.
Seeking anonymity, a number of high-ranked DMCH officials have expressed fears that the smooth operations of the hospital may be hampered due to the standoff between the clinical and para-clinical staff.
Patients are treated for free in public hospitals, but the amount they pay for using diagnostic facilities is called “user fees.” According to existing arrangements, half the amount is allocated to the exchequer, and the remainder is to be disbursed among para-clinical staff, including doctors, lab technicians and employees who carry out testing.
However, following a High Court order, the system of sharing user fees has been suspended for the past two years. Over that period, the entire amount collected- approximately Tk2bn- went to the government exchequer.
On October 10, 2012, following a Civil Leave to Appeal Petition filed by health ministry officials, higher courts issued an interim order for the release of the amount collected as user fees over the past two years. After that order, the health ministry raised the money, which, sources said, was more than Tk1bn.
The clinical staff of government hospitals have been demanding a share of the user fee commission saying the existing arrangement was discriminatory.