A passenger bus in Mithapukur upazila, Rangpur, was bombed on January 14, 2014, killing six, including a child, and injuring 25.
Ten years later, the trial remains unfinished, halted by a 2017 High Court order.
The Attorney General's office negligence led to the case remaining pending for six years. There is uncertainty about when the stay order will be heard. As a result, the trial cannot be concluded while the stay order from the High Court is still in effect.
Local lawyers and human rights activists have called for legal measures to lift the suspension and have expressed frustration that the Attorney General's office has not taken action despite repeated requests, delaying the hearing on lifting the suspension.
How it happened
The BNP-Jamaat alliance supporters had created anarchy across the country ahead of the elections of January 5, 2014 in the name of a blockade. The violent movement continued for a long time resulting in hundreds of deaths and massive loss of public property.
On this day, the passenger bus of Khalil Paribahan left from Ulipur in Kurigram bound for Dhaka. When it reached Batasan area of Mithapukur, Jamaat-Shibir activists who were already there threw several petrol bombs on the moving bus.
The entire bus caught fire and six passengers including children inside the bus were burnt alive. At least 25 passengers were injured. The seriously injured passengers were admitted to the burn unit of Rangpur Medical College Hospital.
Many of the injured are permanently crippled. The police said that most of the passengers were going to Dhaka in search of work and they were all destitute.
Negligence of Attorney General's Office
In 2017, the High Court issued a stay order on the trial proceedings of a horrific arson attack on a bus that killed six people during the BNP-Jamaat's anti-government movement in Rangpur's Mithapukur on January 14, 2015.
Since then, the Attorney General's Office has not taken any initiative to challenge the order and let the trial resume, say justice seekers, lawyers and human rights activists.
Sub-Inspector Abdur Razzak filed the case under the Anti-Terrorism Act at the Mithapukur police station, citing the names of 87 Jamaat Shibir leaders and workers. After investigating the case, Nazrul Islam, then the OC of Mithapukur police, filed the charge sheet against 132 people. Of the accused, 52 people could not be arrested.
The trial started in the First Additional District Sessions Judge Court of Rangpur, and the testimony and cross-examination of 44 out of 60 witnesses were completed.
But the trial process was suspended in 2017 after the defendant appealed to the High Court to quash the proceedings, taking advantage of the police's irresponsibility and flawed investigation.
Family members of the victims have expressed extreme disappointment as the Attorney General's Office is not taking any visible step to ensure justice.
Multiple anonymous lawyers have said that if the Attorney General's office had taken the initiative, the case would not have remained pending for six years.
There is uncertainty about when the stay order will be heard. As a result, the trial cannot be concluded while the stay order from the High Court is still in effect.
What government lawyers are saying
Additional PP Abdus Sattar is one of the lawyers handling the case on behalf of the government.
When contacted, he said: “The case had reached the final stage of trial but it is suspended due to the High Court application for quashment by the accused.”
He expressed hope that once the High Court hearings are concluded, the trial will be quickly completed.
Public Prosecutor and President of Rangpur Legal Association Advocate Abdul Malek said: “Testimonies and cross-examinations of 44 witnesses, including the complainant, have been completed, with a few more remaining.”
In response to a question, he acknowledged that the accused took advantage of flaws in the investigation and said: “The case is stalled as the High Court issued a stay order on the proceedings following the accused's application for dismissal.”
“A letter has been sent to the Attorney General's office to expedite the hearing at the High Court. Once the stay order is lifted, the trial can resume in the lower court,” he added.
A senior lawyer from the Rangpur Bar Association, seeking anonymity, said: “If the Attorney General's office takes initiative at the High Court, the stay order could be lifted. There is now a separate court for trials under the Anti-Terrorism Act. The trial could quickly proceed to judgment after the testimonies of the remaining 4-5 witnesses, including the investigating officer. The reason for the delay in hearing the stay order is unclear.”
Allegations of investigation flaws
A retired police officer from Rangpur, seeking anonymity, said: “Due to the over-enthusiasm of supervising senior officers, the number of accused was unnecessarily inflated, and the investigation was not conducted properly. During testimony in court, the complainant could not name most of the accused apart from 3-4 individuals.”
An anonymous government lawyer mentioned that the police did not consult them during the investigation and filing of the charge sheet.
Complaints from political leaders and human rights activists
Former president of Awami League's Mithapukur Upazila unit, Mojammel Haque Mintu, said: “Most testimonies and cross-examinations have been completed, and the trial could have concluded with the remaining few testimonies. Knowing that they will be surely convicted, the accused moved the case to the High Court."
"They applied for quashment at the High Court, leading it to summon the case files and issue a stay order on the judicial proceedings. However, even after so many years, since the Attorney General's office has not initiated the hearing, the trial cannot be concluded. I demand urgent arrangements for the hearing," he said.
On the other hand, human rights activist Jahangir Hossain Tuhin said: "If a case like burning six bus passengers alive gets stuck in legal technicalities, who is responsible? I demand a swift conclusion of the trial and exemplary punishment for the culprits."