Chief Justice: How will this work?
Publish : 26 May 2017, 01:30
Chief Justice Surendra Kumar Sinha has warned that the parliament’s power to remove judges will create complications if a party does not have absolute majority.
“What will happen if there is no two-thirds majority in parliament to remove a judge who has serious allegations against them?” SK Sinha said on Thursday during a hearing on an appeal filed by the government against a High Court verdict that declared the 16th amendment to the constitution illegal.
The SC is tasked with preserving the constitution, Sinha said.
“Now if something is introduced in it that creates a vacuum, what will happen then? What will the judiciary do? If there is no more than two-thirds majority in parliament, what will happen if a judge is found guilty of serious charges? This worries me.”
The Chief Justice was presiding over a seven-member Appellate Division bench of Supreme Court that will decide the fate of the 16th amendment, which allows parliament to remove judges by a two-thirds majority on the grounds of inefficiency and misconduct.
On the seventh day of hearing on Thursday, proceedings began with Barrister Rokanuddin Mahmud submitting his opinions as an amicus curiae in the case. Senior lawyers TH Khan and M Amir-Ul-Islam also gave opinions.
Barrister Rokanuddin Mahmud quoted remarks made by MPs in parliament about judges from a newspaper.
Members of parliament had made poisonous personal verbal attacks on judges, he said.
“Would you give this power to those who can utter such words in the parliament?”
The members talking about SC judges was a clear violation of parliamentary codes, but despite the legal barrier, the speaker did not utter a word to stop them, Rokanuddin said.
He pointed out that procedure for removal of an official in the civil service, the police and the army were not in the hands of the parliament.
“Their superiors remove them on proven allegations of misconduct. Then why would the impeachment of judges go to parliament?”
The senior lawyer said if there is no Supreme Judicial Council, there will be anarchy.
“If the 16th amendment is sustained, you [Chief Justice] will not be able to say anything to the High Court judges for misconduct.
“If a judge comes to the office late or talks with someone in his chamber, will the parliament be lookin at that? Who will tell them?”
Barrister M Amir-Ul-Islam submitted his opinion before the court after this. Later he told reporters on court premises that in many countries the judiciary looks after its own members’ competence, appointment and removal.
“I have told the court that in our country Supreme Judicial Council should deal with the matter. Parliamentary removals are not effective in any country,” he said.
The prominent lawyer, who is one of the authors of the Constitution, said in reply to a question that at that time the power to impeach judges was given to the parliament because the judiciary was almost nonexistent.
“After Bangabandhu returned, we were searching for a Chief Justice. Then we brought in Sayem. We had not yet built the judiciary at that time. So we gave that power to the parliament, because there was nothing but the parliament back then,” he said.
Afzal H Khan, asked about the written submission of his father TH Khan, said that TH Khan had also opined that the 16th amendment to the constitution should be scrapped.