The Appellate Division of the Supreme Court says firm constitutional guarantees should protect the state including the army from two potential dangers: politicians with military ambitions and military with political ambitions.
The court also recommended a six-point model on how armed forces could be established and control could be exercised on it in a democratic society. It said a clear legal and constitutional framework may define the basic relationship between the state and armed forces.
The court made the observation in the full text of a verdict that upheld a High Court order asking the government to return Tk615.55 crore extracted from businesses and individuals by the army-backed caretaker government in 2007-08.
Also Read- SC: Return confiscated money to businessmen
A four-member bench led by Chief Justice Surendra Kumar Sinha issued the verdict on March 16 this year, rejecting the central bank's appeal. The 89-page verdict has been released recently.
Between April 2007 and Novemebr 2008, the Directorate General of Forces Intelligence (DGFI), on behalf of the then caretaker government, confiscated around Tk1,232 crore from 40 organisations, companies and businesses in the name of collecting VAT, income tax, advance income tax and duty on bond in phases.
After democracy was restored in 2008, 16 companies filed 11 writs between 2009 and 2010 seeking the return of their money amounting to Tk615.55 crore.
Responding to the petitions, the High Court instructed Bangladesh Bank to return the money in separate orders issued in 2010, 2012 and 2013. Later, Bangladesh Bank challenged the verdict with the appeals court and lost the battle on March 16 this year.
The High Court in its verdict observed that the DGFI did not have any authority to collect tax; it was not justified in extracting money from the citizens in the name of taxation without parliament's approval.
“Though the DGFI denied its role in the extortion of money, the documents filed by the Bangladesh Bank clearly show that the money has been collected by Lt Col Md Afzal Naser Bhuiyan of the DGFI,” the appeals court verdict said.
Read More- SC to decide fate of money confiscated by caretaker govt
The court reminded the DGFI that its primary role was “to specialise in the collection, analysis and assessment of military intelligence. Its purpose is to collect, collate and evaluate and disseminate all services strategic and topographical intelligence about law and order situation and armed forces, and to ensure counterintelligence and security measures for Bangladesh and Bangladesh Armed Forces.”
“The High Court Division in the premises has rightly held that 'no situation, be it emergency or otherwise, justifies such action by any Governmental agency to extract money from citizen in the name of taxation without the sanction of Act of Parliament in excess of Constitutional limitations,” the verdict said.
“We take note that though all money were extorted by DGFI and deposited with Bangladesh Bank, the latter tried to justify its action which is reprehensible. It is the custodian of the public money – it has nothing to do with any action of the government or its agencies as to whether those actions were justified or unjustified.”
The apex court suggested that there be a hierarchical responsibility of the military to the government through a civilian organ of public administration – a ministry or department of defence – that is charged, as a general rule, with the direction and supervision of its activities.
The court also put emphasis on the presence of a well-trained and experienced military corps that is respected and funded by a civilian authority. The military corps will acknowledge the principle of civilian control, including the principle of political neutrality and non-partisanship of the armed forces.
The parliament will have a significant role in legislating of defence and security matter, in influencing the formulation of national strategy, in contributing transparency to decisions concerning defence and security policy, in giving budget approval and in controlling expenditure in issues related to the military power.