HC moves to release 'wrongly incarcerated' Arman

The High Court has moved for the release of Md Arman, who has been languishing in jail for the past three years due to a case of mistaken identity by police.

Arman was a Benaroshi Palli artisan in Dhaka’s Pallabi, and was arrested by police on January 27, 2016, mistaken for local drug dealer Shahabuddin Bihari. Shahabuddin is accused in a drug-smuggling case filed with Pallabi police station.

Police and the court mistook Arman for Shahabuddin as both their fathers share the same name, and Arman was sentenced to 10 years imprisonment in the case filed against Shahabuddin on January 29 the same year.

Yesterday, the High Court bench of Justice JBM Hasan and Justice Khairul Alam questioned the legality of Arman’s detention and arrest.

The home secretary, Dhaka district magistrate, police super of Kashimpur Jail, inspector general of police, and officer-in-charge of Pallabi police station have been asked to respond to the rule within the next two weeks. 

The bench also asked why he should be released and given adequate compensation.

Barrister M Humayun Kabir Pallab, who filed the petition seeking Arman’s release, told Dhaka Tribune: “Police arrested Arman after confusing him with local drug dealer Shahabuddin Bihari, as their fathers have the same name. Shahabuddin was accused in a drug-smuggling case filed with Pallabi police station.

“He [Arman] is innocent, but he has been in jail for the past three years being accused and sentenced to 10 years of imprisonment.” 

Because of this mix-up, the real accused Shahabuddin Bihari was not caught and is still running his illegal drug dealing business, while Md Arman is in jail, the barrister said.

The writ seeking Arman’s release was filed by the Law and Life Foundation on April 21. It included a news report published by Bangla national daily Amader Shomoy on April 18 as an attachment.

According to the news report, police detained drug dealer Shahabuddin Bihari and two of his aides - Sohel Mollah and Mamun – from a house in the capital’s Pallabi area on August 30, 2005. 40 yaba pills were confiscated from their possession.

A case was filed over the matter with Pallabi police station, and police submitted a charge sheet against the three accused on September 18 the same year.

While the case was under trial, Shahabuddin secured bail on March 5, 2007. He surrendered to the court and renewed his bail once on January 17, 2011, but has been on the run since.

On October 1, 2012, the court sentenced Shahabuddin and his two associates to 10 years imprisonment, and fined them Tk5,000 each. The court also issued an arrest warrant for the fugitive Shahabuddin.

On January 27, 2016, police arrested Arman, mistaking him for Shahabuddin, and the court sent him to jail on January 29.

In a similar case of mistaken identity, earlier this year, jute factory worker Jahalam was released from jail following a High Court order on February 4.

Jahalam was arrested on February 6, 2016,  mistaken for Abu Salek, accused in 33 cases filed by the ACC in 2014, for loan fraud and embezzlement of Tk18.5 crore from Sonali Bank Limited.