A Dhaka court yesterday handed down the death penalty for five expelled activists of the Bangladesh Chhatra League’s Jahangirnagar University unit and awarded six life imprisonment for the killing, three years ago, of batch mate Zubair Ahmed, an honours final year student of the English department.
Judge ABM Nizamul Haque of the Speedy Trial Tribunal 4 also acquitted two other accused – Md Nazmul Hussain Plabon of the public administration department and Md Mahmudul Hasan Masud of history – as the allegations against them were not proved beyond doubt. They were released from jail.
During the delivery of the sentences, the convicts in the dock burst into tears. They were all students of the 2007-08 session (37th batch).
The five death row convicts, now absconding, are Khandaker Ashikul Islam alias Ashik, Rashedul Islam Raju, Khan Mohammad Rois alias Sohan and Zahid Hasan of the zoology department and Mahabub Akram of the government and politics department.
The lifers are Ishtiaque Mehboob Aroop of the philosophy department, Nazmus Sakib Tapu of biochemistry and molecular biology, Md Kamruzzaman Shohag of philosophy, Abhinandan Kundu Ovi of statistics, Md Mazharul Islam and Shafiul Alam Shetu. They were also fined Tk20,000 each, and, in failure to pay the amount, would have to serve one more year in jail.
Of the 11 convicts, six are on the run. On February 23 last year, Ashik, Rois, Aroop and Akram fled the court while two others – Raju and Zahid – remained absent from their court appearances since January 23 the same year.
After pronouncing the short verdict, the court yesterday issued arrest warrants against all of the fugitives.
The same court on December 18, 2013 sentenced eight Chhatra League activists of Jagannath University to death and 13 others life terms in prison for killing Bishwajit Das, an Old Dhaka tailor, near the Judge’s Court on December 9, 2012.
Zubair, also a former Chhatra League activist, succumbed to his injuries on January 9, 2012 at a hospital in the city. He was beaten and stabbed indiscriminately the previous afternoon on the campus by the convicts and their aides.
The killers took him to Enam Medical College Hospital in Savar and left him there with severe injuries.
Following the incident, university authorities filed a murder case with Ashulia police naming three of the accused – Ashik, Raju and Rois. On January 30 the same year, seven of the accused were expelled from the university for life, while six others were suspended for two years after the authorities found their direct involvement in the murder. The university authorities then asked Ashulia police to add the names of 10 others in the case.
Police filed the charge sheet on April 8, 2012 and the accused were indicted on September 8, 2013. The trial began on November 18, 2013 with the deposition of the plaintiff, Hamidur Rahman, then deputy registrar of the university.
The court completed recording depositions of 27 out of 37 prosecution witnesses on November 27 last year. Two convicts – Akram and Tapu – gave confessional statements before the magistrate.
“It is proven that the accused coordinately attacked the victim in a pre-planned manner over previous enmity. They knew that the attack could lead death to the victim. Examining the witnesses, confessional statements of two accused, probe report of the university authorities and evaluating the circumstances, it has been proved beyond doubt that the accused killed the victim,” the court said in its verdict.
The court said Ashik, Raju and Zubair had joined Jatiyatabadi Chhatra Dal, BNP’s student wing, after their admission in 2008. A year later they joined Chhatra League after the government changed. But they belonged to two factions of the ruling Awami League’s student body.
“They had enmity. The university probe committee and testimonies of a number of professors clearly identified them,” the court said.
About the acquittals, the judge said: “During the hearing, lawyers of Plabon and Masud firmly claimed that they were not involved in the attack but rather they tried to save Zubair. Plabon was present on the spot when the victim was being beating up. Failing to save him, Plabon called Masud over the phone seeking assistance.”
The court also mentioned the testimonies of several members of the university’s probe committee and the police report.
Judge Nizamul also observed that the expulsion orders for two years on Plabon and Masud should be reconsidered.
Condemning the current trend of student politics, the judge suggested that proper guidelines be formulated to evade murders, violence and other unethical acts at the public universities.
The tribunal was set to deliver the verdict on February 4, but the date was deferred since the police had not produced the seven convicts before the court from Dhaka Central Jail.
Talking to reporters after the verdict, Jamal Uddin Khandaker, lawyer of four convicts, said two of his clients had been awarded life terms while two others were acquitted. “We will go to the higher court seeking justice for Mazharul and Shohag after getting a copy of the full verdict.”
Mixed reaction of victim’s family
When contacted, Zubair’s father Tofayel Ahmed said: “We expected that all 13 accused would be warded death sentences. Still we are happy with the verdict.”
Zubair’s brother Abdullah Al-Mamun alleged that some fugitive convicts were roaming around in broad daylight. He urged the government to arrest them immediately and execute the verdict at the earliest opportunity.
“We heard that death row convict Ashik is now in Malaysia while Rois is in Denmark. Students told us that they saw some convicts visiting the campus regularly and they also attended the RAG programme of the 37th batch,” he said.
Rois, now believed to be in Denmark, in an interview via Facebook with the Dhaka Tribune on Tuesday, claimed that he had not been present at the scene. Asked why he had fled the court, Rois claimed that he wanted to save his life since the country’s law would not do justice to him.
Acquitted Masud, who had been expelled for two years after the probe body had found his involvement in the killing, was appointed as a computer operator at the university in early 2013. He was sacked from his job recently.
After the verdict, President of the JU unit of Chhatra League Mahmudur Rahman Jony claimed that those convicted by the court did not belong to the student organisation since the unit’s activities had been postponed at that time. He expressed satisfaction over the verdict.
Students under the banner of “Shontrasher Biruddhe Jahangirnagar” brought out a procession on the campus welcoming the verdict.
According to his friends, Zubair had sensed that he could be attacked by the rival group at any time during the exams. On that fateful day, he phoned the authorities to ask them to provide him with security.
Zubair had been staying off campus, at Savar, since he quit politics a year before, following a crackdown against the Chhatra League faction he was loyal to. He did not attend classes regularly and only went to campus to sit for exams.
Probe bodies
After the incident of torture of January 8, 2012, the university authorities formed a proctorial probe body that submitted its report the same night.
As the involvement of Ashik, Raju and Rois was proved in preliminary investigations, the disciplinary board at a meeting the following morning suggested the expulsion of the trio for a year.
The university Syndicate at an emergency meeting at 11am approved the decision and formed another committee to deal with the case.
The university authorities published the expulsion order on January 10. The same day, the three students were expelled for life upon getting further evidence.
The six-member probe committee recommend the expulsion of seven students for life, and two years for six others.
Following the incident, students and teachers started agitation demanding punishment of the attackers and those in the administration who allegedly provided them shelter.
The authorities in mid-January accepted the resignation of then proctor Arzu Mia and transferred security officer Azim Uddin. After several months’ of agitation, then VC Shariff Enamul Kabir resigned from his post.
‘Public universities affected by national politics’
In his observation, Judge Nizamul expressed frustration over the current political situation at the public universities. He suggested that guidelines be formulated for student politics in order to stop the recurrence of violent acts.
“The investigation officer has unearthed the current trend of student politics which is highly chaotic, and that lacks ideals and values,” the court said, adding that the practice of muscle politics hampers the establishment of a congenial environment for academic activities.
Mentioning that Ashik, Raju and Zubair had switched party with the change in power in 2009, the judge said: “This trend [of switching organisation] has divided the ruling party’s student front; it also encourages unethical activities including factional clashes, torture of members of rival student organisations, extortion, tender manipulation, physical and mental torture [ragging] of students, sexual harassment, misconduct with teachers, violating rules of universities and cheating in exams.”
The court also said the situation could not be contained properly even by the universities’ highest policy-making body, the Syndicate.
“The killing of Zubair is the extreme result of the continuation of such unethical activities. Such unnecessary murder questions humanity and morals over and over again.”
The judge said the impunity enjoyed by criminals for murders and violence in recent years had inspired such acts in the public universities significantly. “These acts frighten the students and their parents while creating a negative impression about student politics,” Judge Nizamul added.