JS body: MPs cannot be both complainant and executor

The parliamentary watchdog examining the 16th constitution amendment bill yesterday suggested that the government must not allow MPs to be both complainant and executor while framing the law that would govern investigation into alleged “misconduct and incapacity” of apex court judges.

Before finalising its recommendations on the charter-changing bill, the parliamentary standing committee suggested Law Minister Anisul Huq to enact the law in three months.

The minister agreed with such suggestion of the 10-member watchdog, but turned down the committee’s earlier proposal of holding talks with legal academics, jurists, former judges and other stakeholders before finalisation of the recommendations on the bill.

In its recommendation, the standing committee cut the long preamble of the 16th constitution amendment bill that the law minister tabled in the legislature on Sunday.

The committee chairman, Suranjit Sengupta, told reporters that he was likely to table the committee recommendations today.

“We are not holding talks with the stakeholders on this bill as we have already cut the preamble and other redundant words and reinserted the exact article 96 of the 1972 constitution. So, there is no need for talks with anyone,” Suranjit told journalists after the meeting at the parliament building.

On Tuesday, the standing committee tasked the law minister to talk to Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina and other senior leaders of the ruling party to decide whether the standing committee would invite different stakeholders to finalise its recommendations on the constitution amendment bill.

Law minister Anisul Huq told journalists that the government was against holding talks with stakeholders on the constitution amendment bill.

“Rather, we will have talks with all stakeholders while enacting the law,” said Anisul.

Meanwhile, speaking on the proposed committee that would investigate charges against judges, Suranjit said: “I think the committee must have representatives from the judiciary, so that we do not become both the complainant and justice.”

Abdul Matin Khasru, a member of the standing committee, told the Dhaka Tribune that the watchdog had strongly suggested that the investigative committee must probe the allegations against the judges impartially.

Referring to Indian cases, the former law minister said a three-member panel of judges investigated the charges against their judges. The legislature would then discuss the panel’s report for either adoption for removal or rejection, he said.

But former home minister and also a committee member, Shahara Khatun, told reporters: “Very often different allegations against the judges and magistrates surface and you [journalists] also write about it in the newspapers. We can investigate the allegations”.

Khasru, however, rejected Shahara’s idea, saying: “Unless we finalise the modus operandi, we cannot talk about it. But the committee’s strong suggestion is we have to protect the dignity of the Supreme Court, our last resort”.

In line with the suggestion of the Law Commission – the authorised body to suggest the executive on legal reforms – the government decided to restore the original article 96 of the constitution that authorised the legislature to remove Supreme Court judges for “misconduct and incapacity.”

In 1975, the Awami League government curtailed the legislature’s authority over the judiciary and imposed the same to the president. Military ruler Ziaur Rahman in 1978 introduced a new mechanism: the Supreme Judicial Council headed by the chief justice. Two other senior judges are the members of the three-member commission tasked to remove the judges for similar grounds.

If passed, the bill would re-empower the legislature to remove the judges for “misconduct and incapacity,” proved through an investigation of the committee.