Constitution’s 16th amendment bill placed in JS

Law Minister Anisul Huq yesterday fumbled twice and corrected text before tabling the Constitution (16th amendment) Bill 2014 that would authorise the legislature to impeach Supreme Court judges for “misbehaviour and incapacity.”

The copy of the draft law reads that the second military order in 1978 “put in place the Supreme Judicial Council to remove the Supreme Court Judges instead of the Jatiya Sangsad.”

While tabling the bill, Anisul dropped the phrase “instead of the Jatiya Sangsad,” apparently realising the mistake in the draft.

He started by saying: “Honourable speaker, I want to table the bill in corrected form,” and read out rest of the sentences in the preamble of the bill, but did not mention what the mistake was.

Parliament Secretariat officials told the Dhaka Tribune that the Fourth Amendment in 1975 had curtailed the authority of the legislature to remove Supreme Court judges and vested the power in the president who became the centre of all power.

Military ruler Maj Gen Ziaur Rahman, who usurped state power after the assassination of Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman, promulgated the military order in 1978 to introduce unconstitutionally the Supreme Judicial Council headed by the chief justice.

At 7:10pm, Speaker Shirin Sharmin Chaudhury, who chaired yesterday’s sitting, asked the law minister to seek permission of the House to table the bill.

Flanked by Chief Whip ASM Feroz on the left and former chief whip Abdus Shahid on the right, the law minister first read out the preamble of the bill and said: “I have tabled the Constitution (16th amendment) Bill 2014.”

The speaker and Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina, who was sitting in the first row, intervened and suggested that Anisul, sitting in the second row, should seek permission of the House to initiate the bill.

Anisul fumbled again, prompting the other members including Leader of the House Hasina, Abdus Shahid and State Minister for Labour and Employment Mujibul Haque to correct him.

The premier looked at him, revolving her chair. Anisul then corrected and said: “Honourable speaker, I seek the permission of the House to table the Constitution (16th amendment) Bill 2014.”

As there was no opposition, the minister then tabled the bill, and the whole House having around 230 MPs celebrated it by thumping desks.

Mujibul Haque and State Minister for Local Government Mashiur Rahman Ranga were particularly euphoric.

Leader of the Opposition Rawshan Ershad, who attended the sitting before the Maghrib prayers, remained absent when the bill was placed.

On August 31, the Jatiya Party parliamentary party decided that they would oppose the constitution amendment bill “like a true opposition.”

In line with the parliamentary rule, the bill went to the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Law Ministry for further examination. The watchdog will send its recommendations to the assembly in seven days.

It apparently means that the bill is set to pass in the current session which may end on September 18.

If passed, not only the judges, parliament will also have the power to remove the chief election commissioner and commissioners of the Election Commission, the chairman and members of the Public Service Commission, the chairman and commissioners of the Anti-Corruption Commission, and the comptroller and auditor general on similar grounds.

The articles establishing the EC, the PSC, the ACC and the office of the Comptroller and Auditor General stipulate that the holders of the constitutional posts would be removed according to the procedures applicable for the removal of the Supreme Court judges.

At present, the Supreme Judicial Council can remove the apex court judges for misconducts and incapacity. Two senior judges are members of the council, a mechanism put in place by Ziaur Rahman through the second military proclamation in 1978.

According to the bill, parliament would impeach judges for “proven misconducts and inabilities” with a two-thirds majority in the assembly and the legislature would enact a law governing investigation of the charges against the judges.

In line with the law, the report on the investigation into the allegations would go to parliament in the form of a motion of impeachment. The House would hold discussions on it, giving the judges scope to defend themselves, and remove them if the charges are proved.

The bill does not bring any changes to the provision of judges’ current retirement age, which is 67.

The draft law terms the Supreme Judicial Council opposed to the spirit of the constitution’s article 7 that says the people are source of all power.

It further says the legislature can remove the president, the prime minister and speaker of the Jatiya Sangsad, but not the judges of the Supreme Court. So, the judges should also be accountable to the people through the legislature, which is elected by the people.

The bill says the restoration of article 96 of the constitution would enhance people’s confidence on the judiciary and restore the basic spirit of the constitution.

It says the provision for removal of the judges has been practised in many countries in the world.

According to the directives of the Supreme Court, the Awami League government on June 30, 2011 passed the 15th amendment to restore the provisions of the original constitution framed in 1972. Through this, the provision of non-party caretaker government was dropped.

Many of the MPs demanded restoration of the original article 96 of the constitution that empowered the legislature to impeach apex court judges for misconduct and inabilities. But the government refrained from doing so, apparently not to antagonise the judiciary.

Tasked by the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Law Ministry, the Law Commission in April sent a set of proposals to speed up the disposal of the pending cases. The commission recommended that the government restore article 96 to make the judges accountable.

In line with the report of the Law Commission, the cabinet approved the proposal to restore article 96 of the 1972 constitution.