Vehicles avoid Hanif flyover because of ‘excessive’ tolls

The much-anticipated Mayor Mohammad Hanif Flyover which was built to ease the capital’s traffic burden and bring relief to the Dhaka residents has failed to live up to the expectations, allegedly because of the “excessive” tolls being charged by the flyover operators.

A large number of people who regularly travel on the route have been refusing to pay the flyover tolls which they considered as exorbitant, and have been preferring to use the road under the flyover to save money instead of time.

Md Hafiz, a bus driver, alleged the flyover operators of collecting “excess charges” from all vehicles in the name of tolls.

Alamgir Miah, a tea seller at Kutubkhali toll plaza, said most vehicles were avoiding the flyover and taking the streets, not only because of the fees but also because of traffic congestion on the bridge caused by “poor bridge management.”

Orion Infrastructure Ltd built the Tk2.3bn flyover, popularly known as the Jatrabari-Gulistan Flyover, in what was the country’s first Public-Private Partnership initiative. Constructed on a build-own-operate-transfer (BOOT) basis, Orion is the official concessionaire at the flyover, which is slated to be handed over to the government after a concession period of 24 years.

However, since the flyover’s opening on October 11, the company has allegedly continued to charge double the rates mentioned in the original contract paper – more than double, in some cases – in the name of recuperating the cost of construction and maintenance.

While visiting the flyover’s toll plaza last week, it was found that the Orion operators charged a trailer Tk375 for a single trip, compared to the contract-fixed toll of Tk200.

Similarly, the operators charged Tk260 for six-wheeler trucks instead of the contract-fixed Tk150, Tk173 for four-wheeler trucks instead of Tk100, Tk260 for buses instead of Tk150, Tk173 for minibuses instead of Tk100, Tk130 for pickup vans instead of Tk75, Tk85 for microbuses instead of Tk50, Tk70 for SUVs instead of Tk40, Tk60 for cars instead of Tk35, Tk18 for auto-rickshaws instead of Tk10, and Tk10 for motorbikes instead of Tk5.

The company had also put up a self-styled toll chart on display at the plaza, without prior negotiation with and permission from the government.

Meanwhile, disputes over the toll-increase at the flyover have landed its builders in court.

Orion Infrastructure Ltd – the project’s sole private-sector partner – filed a writ petition seeking permission for charging additional fees, while the Dhaka South City Corporation (DSCC) – the public-sector authority of the project – had termed the practice “illegal.”

However, the objection was made ineffective by a stay order issued in Orion’s favour, following the petition.

According to sources, the DSCC had sent two letters to Orion in October, urging it to stop collecting the higher tolls. However, Orion stood by its decision and filed a writ petition with the High Court earlier this month seeking its intervention.

The High court ordered the DSCC to stop its interference in the matter, based on which the private company continued its collection of higher tolls.

In this regard, Chowdhury Khaled Masud, manager for the supply chain at Orion Group, told the Dhaka Tribune: “The toll chart shown by the DSCC was prepared at the time of submitting the project proposal in 2003.

“It is no longer acceptable in the present context, because costs of everything have gone up in the last 10 years. Plus, the length of the flyover had been expanded beyond what was planned originally, requiring additional costs,” he added.

DSCC Chief Executive Officer Ansar Ali Khan admitted receiving a copy of the High Court order, and said they were waiting for the LGRD ministry’s decision about taking legal action in this regard.

“This is not acceptable. The construction company should stick to the original toll chart, as was the deal during the contract signing in 2005,” he added.

Orion official Masud, however, claimed they did not need to take permission from the government to increase the toll rates, since the contract had “allowed us [Orion] to revise the tariff every year.”

Meanwhile, since Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina inaugurated the flyover on October 11, there have been various reports of scuffles breaking out between toll collectors and bridge users over the charges.