The cow and why

Qurbani is back. Oh, how I’ve missed it! The amazing fragrance of freshly cooked meat, the mind-blowing taste of just prepared beef, the thankful pleasure of dining with the family – the countdown to the cattle buying extravaganza has begun.

When granddads, fathers and sons flock to the market, they bargain and they holler. They become shocked at some prices, and they laugh inside at others. Always they wonder, why is it one price today and something else tomorrow? Why do prices fluctuate so much? It is time to uncover the cow and why.

This week, I have watched how the prices of cattle heaves up and down as time progresses towards the much awaited Eid-ul-Azha. At the beginning of the week, cattle dealers and owners were upping their prices in the hope of getting good deals.

As the week progressed, however, the market value of cattle dropped. Next week, expect to see prices stoop to their lowest two-to-three days before Eid, before rising once more until the midnight before Eid day. Then something incredible happens: the price drops again, and keeps plummeting for every passing moment before Eid morning as dealers rush to clear their stocks.

For unorthodox activity like the once a year sale of cattle, why does the price fluctuate so much in the haats? The key to understanding cattle market economics is acknowledging the role human expectations play in determining market price. If people expect the price to be high, dealers set the price high. The opposite is also true because when people believe the price will be low, dealers cannot go in too high with their opening price. Although obvious, the implications of this theory are wonderful to observe.

Prices invariably start high, but as market days pass traders realise they are not selling enough to make the amount of profit they envision. Many buyers in turn take a tactic of waiting and watching until the market price comes down. These two conditions together lower the price of cattle to the point where both the buyers and sellers expectations are met. The low-price period continues until two-to-three days before Eid day.

But when traders feel the slow trickle of customers becoming a stampede, the price goes up again to maintain balance between this aggravated demand but almost static supply. Traders as a result hike up the price to maximise revenues.

After midnight before Eid Day, however, the sellers begin to realise they still have a lot of unsold cattle. Having spent so much money transporting their stock to haats, and spending on their own lodgings, the traders want to at least recoup their unit cost investment before they move out. Hence they try to sell off their cattle at whatever price they can above cost.

If everyone flocked to the market after midnight to grab themselves a bovine bargain, would they all get that ultra-low price? The answer is no, because the reason prices fall after midnight is that demand drops below supply. If demand held up, so would the price.

So now you know. When you embark on the adventure of bringing home the best cow and goat you can lay your hands on this weekend and next week, just pause for a moment. Look into the eyes of the trader, and allow yourself a smile.

Because now you know what they’re thinking; but will they know what you are?