The Election Commission (EC) on Tuesday tried to justify its move, at the law ministry's suggestion, to exclude article 91(E) from the Representation of the People Order (RPO), which had empowered it to cancel candidature for gross violation of the electoral code of conduct.
Chief Election Commissioner Kazi Rakibuddin Ahmad, in a press briefing at the EC secretariat, spoke publicly on the issue for the first time and claimed that scrapping the provision would not weaken the commission.
However, the commission's amendment proposal sent to the law ministry for vetting last Thursday included the article. The proposal was sent back, for the fourth time, with the suggestion to leave out the article, taking the power to cancel candidature out of the EC's hand and giving it to the government.
Deeming the article "self-contradictory, meaningless and inapplicable", the CEC claimed: "If it exists in the RPO, it would create discrimination among the candidates of the election."
Rakibuddin pointed out that the provision was not there in the order previously and was included in 2008. He pointed out that the provision to cancel candidature creates scope of discrimination as once the EC cancels candidature, the other candidates get the benefit and it was not rational to cancel candidature in the shortest time without consideration.
"If any candidature is cancelled for violating the electoral code of conduct, the EC could hold election among the rest of candidates. If a lone candidate is legal and other candidature cancelled, the article 91(E) states that to re-announce the polls schedule. However, the lone candidate had no faults so why should he or she go through the suffering."
The article 91(E) (1) stated that if any serious allegation rises against any candidate or his representative or one of supporters by the any sources and if the allegation proves, the EC would cancel the candidacy of the candidate. The EC could also form investigation committee in this regard.
Article 91(E) (2) stated that after receiving the investigation report, the EC has to issue a written order to cancel the candidacy of the candidate and the election would be held with other candidates of concerned constituency. If a lone candidate of the constituency is found to be only legal, the election would be held under Article 17.
The CEC pointed out that the provision contradicted Article 19, which states that if returning officers found a lone candidate legal after scrutinising nominations, the candidate should be declared the winner.
The CEC also said candidates do not get right judgment under the laws and that in case of serious allegations against the candidates, the matter should go to court. If the court feels that candidature should be scrapped, the EC could implement the verdict.
He continued that if the law presents disadvantages then it is not applicable. "So if a law is not applicable, there is no need to have it in the RPO."
Replying to a question, the CEC said that there were procedures to punish candidates violating the electoral laws which would still be in place allowing the commission to tackle violations.
However, Rakibuddin refused to answer questions about the reduction of the commission's power this change would bring. "I do not want to comment in this regard."
Election commissioner Abdul Mobarak said that the EC was strong enough without the candidature cancelling authority.