Zakat fund runs dry

The government's zakat fund has recently seen a slide in deposits, whereas private commercial banks and other firms have been collecting money for their own accounts to distribute among the poor, which violates the Zakat Fund Ordinance 1982.

The Zakat Board has questioned the accountability and transparency of the operation of these private zakat funds, as it had thought the poor were not receiving the benefits of the Islamic system through these private initiatives.

An official of the board Tuesday said the Zakat Board had opened an account several years ago to collect funds from 42 commercial banks but most of these banks had not paid any amount to the government's zakat fund at the end of the last fiscal year.

Official sources said most of these banks had opened separate bank accounts to collect money from their wealthy clients, which is not legal under the Zakat Fund Ordinance 1982.

Zakat, which in Islam is a compulsory payment for every mentally sound, free and financially able adult Muslim to help the poor, is a 2.5% levy on one's most valuables and savings if their total value is greater than a basic minimum.

Dr Kabir Hasan, a professor at New Orleans University, USA, in a research paper says: "If zakat fund is collected and managed properly, it can be used to create a pool of funds, which can be used in financing development activities and can replace government expenditures."

In Bangladesh, zakat funds could have contributed up to 21% of the ADP in 1983-1984 and up to 43% in 2004-2005, he said.

The Zakat Board said the commercial banks collected money from people, in a move that was not legitimate as the government had already established the board under the Zakat Fund Ordinance 1982, and it was the board's sole authority to collect and distribute zakat money.

The board also raised questions as to how much money these commercial banks had collected for the zakat fund, because the Bangladesh Bank did not have any information in this regard.

It said the commercial banks' funds were mostly used in the education and health sectors, and to build hospitals and religious structures such as mosques, which it said was illegal.

The board found that the Islami Bank Bangladesh spent its zakat fund for the Islami Bank Foundation in 2011.

Bangladesh Bank Governor Dr Atiur Rahman told the Dhaka Tribune that the commercial banks were collecting and distributing zakat through their own authorities as humanitarian banking.

"They did not submit any separate report on the collection of zakat fund but they have mentioned the fund in their annual reports," he said.

On the legality of such funds he said it did not directly violate the Bank Company Act "but these operations of collecting and distributing zakat fund should be maintained through transparency and accountability."

Requesting anonymity, a high official of the Zakat Board told the Dhaka Tribune that the number of rich people had increased over the years but the amount of zakat had not increased because of a lack of campaign.

Mohammed Nurul Amin, chairman of the Association of Bankers Bangladesh and managing director of the NCC Bank, declined to comment on the Zakat Board's allegations, but he claimed that most commercial banks had not deposited their collection because the response from people had been very poor.

The Zakat Board data shows of the 42 commercial banks only 14 had collected Tk60.3m during FY2012-13 but the board distributed only Tk2m.

The remaining 28 commercial banks did not collect any money for the Zakat Board although they opened separate accounts and collected over Tk10m each. These banks, however, did not disclose how they spent the funds.

A few commercial banks, such as the First Security Islami Bank, Shahjalal Islami Bank, and Social Islami Bank, claim to be operating Islamic banking, but they have failed to mobilise funds for the Zakat Board although they collected money in their own accounts.