War criminal Ghulam Azam’s chief counsel barrister Abdur Razzaq Monday said there were no examples in the world where punishment was relaxed considering the convict’s age.
“Such an example is yet to be found all around the world in which the age of a convict has been taken into consideration while delivering a verdict,” he told the Dhaka Tribune Monday.
He said no punishment should be applicable against Ghulam Azam.
About the rumour that Bangladesh Jamaat-e-Islami had reached an understanding with the government regarding the verdict in Ghulam Azam’s case, Razzaq said: “People, who are not satisfied with the verdict, tend to assume that there was an understanding or negotiation.”
He also questioned the role of the International Crimes Tribunal and claimed that it did not meet the international standards.
Earlier at a press briefing in the afternoon, Razzaq had said they would appeal to the higher court against the verdict.
“We resent the verdict. We believe that it is against the spirit of justice and was driven by emotion. It would be very hard to find another such verdict in the history of criminal lawsuits,” he had read out from a written statement at the briefing at his Dhanmondi chamber.
He said: “The prosecution has failed to prove beyond doubt any of the 61 counts of the charges brought against him [Ghulam Azam]. It is an utter failure of the prosecution.”
Razzaq highlighted the anomalies in the verdict that ICT 1 pronounced against Ghulam Azam.
He said: “Charges against Ghulam Azam were brought because he had meetings with the then Pakistan president Yahia Khan, Tikka Khan and Maulana Moududi. However, the prosecution failed to submit the minutes of any of those meetings or say what was discussed in those meetings. Meeting someone is not a crime against humanity and such criteria did not fall into the definition of crime against humanity.
“The verdict is totally unacceptable according to the law.”
He said if being involved with the formation of the Shanti Committee was a crime, the definition of the term “crimes against humanity” had to be changed.
Regarding the third and fourth charges against Ghulam, the chief defence counsel said: “The investigation officer of the case has accepted that he did not have any information on any crime that occurred after hearing the speeches of Ghulam Azam in 1971.”
Regarding the killing of Seru Mia, Razzaq said the prosecution had failed to submit the letter, which had been allegedly found responsible for Seru Mia’s killing. Yet the tribunal had sentenced Ghulam to 30 years in prison – such an incident would not be found in the last 200 years’ history of criminal procedure.
Admitting that Ghulam believed in the unity of Pakistan, Razzaq claimed that believing in and working in favour of the independence and sovereignty of Pakistan could not be synonymous with committing genocide and crimes against humanity.
He also said they did not believe that the charges brought against Ghulam had anything that might substantiate his involvement with genocide or crimes against humanity.
Replying to a query, Razzaq claimed that the tribunal’s observations on Jamaat’s involvement in crimes against humanity as a party was completely unacceptable and in complete breach of laws.
“The judges of the tribunal have failed to deliver the verdict considering the proof and documents related to the incidents, which made them fail to fulfil their responsibility. Most of their observations are basically on issues which are out of the purview of the trial,” Razzaq said.