Former chief justice ABM Khairul Haque is not willing to specify which one from the two options he had suggested in the historic verdict on the 13th amendment to the constitution would be appropriate for the next national elections.
In an exclusive interview with the Dhaka Tribune, the immediate past chief justice stated that he had left several recommendations in the judgement since he was not certain which option the political parties would choose to resolve the crisis.
Justice Khairul said he could suggest a single option only if he knew beforehand which one would be effective. However, he does not want to spend time on the matter any more. He believes he has done his job “properly”.
The jurist is now planning to perform hajj along with his wife in the next session of the religious event. He has already contacted an agent and is trying to collect the necessary funds. Of the estimated cost of Tk1m, he has got Tk800,000 in hand.
However, he is afraid he might miss the hajj this year if he fails to manage the rest.
In the verdict, delivered on May 10, 2011, the Appellate Division declared the non-party caretaker government system illegal, but at the same time, observed that the next two national elections could be arranged under this system if the parliament decides so.
The full verdict was released on Septmber 16, 2012. Of the seven judges of the apex court, four -- former chief justice ABM Khairul Haque, Chief Justice Md Muzammel Hossain, Justice SK Sinha and Justice Syed Mahmud Hossain -- were in favour of declaring the caretaker provision unconstitutional; two -- Justice MA Wahhab Miah and Justice Nazmun Ara Sultana -- were for keeping the provision; and one -- Justice Md Imman Ali -- opined that the matter should be left to parliament.
The ruling Awami League hailed the verdict, but it was not warmly accepted by the opposition when a confusion ran through the country’s political arena whether the next parliamentary elections should be held under the caretaker government system or any new form.
Till today, the Awami League seems firm enough in its position not to conduct the next general elections, possibly by the end of this year, under the caretaker government as demanded by the opposition parties, especially the BNP.
The main opposition party has also warned the government a dozen times that it would not let any national elections be held under a partisan government. Opinion polls suggest that many people also favour the caretaker system as an interim government because of lack of confidence in the leading political parties to administer free and fair elections.
The caretaker government under which the last three elections were held, was introduced first in 1996 (the 1990 elections were held under an interim government). The BNP introduced the caretaker government system through the 13th amendment as the then opposition Awami League staged street protest demanding election under a non-party administration.
But the system was called into question as the last military-backed caretaker government in 2007 prolonged its tenure to two years though it had a mandate to hold the elections within three months.
The Awami League-led grand alliance government abolished the provision through the 15th amendment in June 2011.
Justice Khairul thinks the political parties must pick a solution, through consensus, among those stated in the verdict to hold the next general elections. And the solution should come through discussion.
He said it is the lawmakers who will decide whether the polls would be held under a caretaker government or an interim government formed by representatives selected by the lawmakers.
But, whatever system the political parties pick, the Election Commission should play the key role holding the elections and there should not be any scope for the caretaker government or a small-sized interim cabinet to play any role in it. The ministers will have no power to influence the election. That is why the verdict suggested that the EC be made all-powerful to arrange the general elections.
The verdict at first clearly states the caretaker government system is illegal and annulled. Secondly, the verdict has also mentioned that although the system is cancelled, it can be followed for two more terms. However, the political parties will decide how they will deal with it.
The verdict has also given the option of picking the former chief justice as the head of the caretaker government if the political parties want. The law enforcement agencies and others who will get involved directly or indirectly with the elections will work under the EC in order to hold a free, fair and neutral election. After the election schedule is announced, the security forces – members of police, Rab, BGB, and army – will not listen to the government orders but the commands of the EC until the results are declared.
The EC will have the authority to take action against anyone attempting to influence the statutory body. Similar provisions are available in India and the UK.
On the viewpoint that there is no chance the political parties will reach any solution, Justice Khairul said: “It is up to the political parties what they will do. I have finished my task. Now, the political leaders will do their job. I do not know what they will do.”
Replying to another query as to why he did not specifically suggested method of the next national election, he said: “That would not have been a right thing to do … might seemed imposed. What has been done is correct.” Questions baseless
The former chief justice’s observation was sought on the point that the ruling Awami League has accepted a part-judgement – cancellation of the system – while the main opposition BNP has welcomed the other part that suggests holding of the national polls under the caretaker government for next two terms.
Justice Khairul said the parties agree with the verdict partially as per their benefits. “All problems will be resolved if the parties accept the whole verdict.”
He reads the copy of the verdict whenever he hears criticism against it, and every time he discovers that he has given a “perfect judgement.”
He says he often laughs at criticisms against the verdict made by many on the television talk-shows. He understands that many persons criticise his verdict without reading it.
A former minister of a BNP-led government one day on a television talk-show criticised the judgement saying that Justice Khairul had cancelled the caretaker government system centring the incident of Moon Cinema Hall, recounted Justice Khairul with a laugh. He said he cancelled the 5th amendment to the constitution centring the Moon Cinema Hall. The former minister made the claim without even knowing about the 13th amendment.
Justice Khairul said sometimes the contents of the television talk-shows give him pain.
“Through the television channels’ talk-shows I have recently heard that BNP leaders Sadeque Hossain Khoka, Enam Ahmed Chowdhury and Rafiqul Islam Mia are lying without thoroughly reading the full verdict. They are saying that there is no similarity between the short verdict and the detailed verdict. But, the reality is that they are making such comment without reading the judgement. In both the judgements the provision of caretaker government has been kept. If the politicians entertain the chance, they will be able to keep a similar caretaker government like before or they will be able to form another caretaker government in new fashion.”
The political parties will have to find a solution by picking an option or the crisis will deepen if they fail. Some people are trying to make it an issue because if they accept the verdict there will have no option in front of them. And they will also have no option to deliver indecent words. This group of people does not want a solution to the problems because they will not be able to fight if the problem is resolved. To quarrel, they need issues. And that is why the crisis is yet to be resolved, opined this eminent jurist.
The full verdict on the 13th amendment was published on September 16 last year, nearly 16 months after the order was passed.
Asked about his stance if the political parties agree to hold the next two national elections under the caretaker government and request him to take the charge, Justice Khairul replied: “If any political party gives this proposal I will catch the next flight to London to stay with my daughter living there. I will not stay even in the country.”
He said the High Court declared the 13th amendment legal and according to the laws.
The appeal made with the Appellate Division in this regard was to judge whether the HC verdict was illegal. Since the HC declared the amendment legal, so the issue for the Appellate Division was to determine whether it was illegal or legal. The Appellate Division found the amendment illegal and also contradictory to the constitution. It could not speak going beyond the issue. Many things were written in the verdict considering the real situation. But there was no scope of going beyond the main focus.
Solution within verdict
Many people think that there is no scope in the verdict to resolve the political crisis. Justice Khairul, however, thinks that the solution lies in the verdict and the crisis will also go away if the recommendations are followed.
Two processes have been mentioned in the verdict for resolving the crisis. If there was no process mentioned in the verdict, then it could have been said that the verdict would not be able to remove the standoff, he said.
One process states that the parliament has to be dissolved 42 days before the national elections and a small-scale cabinet can be formed. The parliament will decide how that cabinet will be constituted. As criticism is raised against unelected persons, the verdict batted for the elected representatives. Because it thinks a government without representatives selected by the people cannot be acceptable.
According to Justice Khairul, the 42-day time is logical to hold the national elections. All election-related activities can be done within this time-frame. But, if the lawmakers deem it necessary, they may revise the time-frame to 30 or 60 days. If they do not like this process, they can keep the caretaker government system for the next two terms to hold the national elections although it is illegal and contradictory to the constitution.
The verdict has also spoken for not considering the former chief justice or justices as the head of the caretaker government. However, if the political parties fail to reach any consensus, they can again go with the idea of selecting the former chief justice or the justices as the head of the caretaker government or other advisers of the government. It will depend on the lawmakers.
“Being a judge, I cannot deliver any directive for the parliament. And that is why I ensured different ways and also spoke for what can be done and what are the necessities. These two options have been kept technically. I think the lawmakers will have to go for one in the future whatever form of government they pick,” Justice Khairul said.
Unelected governments did not get acceptance anywhere across the globe because these are formed without representatives selected by the people. Here, the government can be formed with the people’s representatives. In case of forming a caretaker government, the option of forming it from the people’s representatives has been kept in the judgement.
Another amendment needed
Over the cancellation of the caretaker government provision through 15th amendment before the full verdict was released, Justice Khairul said: “It was not a proper way. They [AL] will have to move forward in line with the verdict. That is why the way they are trying to hold the elections under the incumbent government by bringing amendment [to the constitution] will not ultimately work out. Because, apart from forming a small-scale cabinet, the matter of dissolving parliament before 42 days has been mentioned in the full verdict. So, it will not be possible to hold the elections keeping all [lawmakers] in power.
“The parliament needs to be dissolved. Since they [AL] have made new provision bringing an amendment, now they will have to bring another amendment [to the constitution]. In US, a president does not resign in the presidential election. Even, the senate members do not resign before the senate elections. The same process exists in India. Although there is no instance of resigning or dissolving parliament before the elections seen in any other country, I have suggested this process for a free, fair and neutral election in Bangladesh.”
EC to be strengthened
In response to another query whether the EC would have much authority to work during the national elections, the former chief justice said the verdict clearly states about the process of making the EC powerful. “If the quarters, which will remain involved with the election process, do not go beyond the directives of the commission, there will not be any problem for the commission to hold the elections.”
Happy with verdict
Asked to comment on an observation that there is no solution in the verdict but only uncertainty, he said: “It is not correct.
There is no uncertainty. The political parties will have to reach the solution by picking one from the two options. And, once they pick one option they will find the solution. I am very hopeful about the verdict. I have told everything in eight pages from 337 to 341 and I will request all to read these pages.”
On the query, how the two major parties will reach to consensus since the parties are not interested to hold dialogue between them and are not in the parliament together, Justice Khairul said they will have to reach to solution. There is no alternative to finding a solution or reaching consensus.
“Although there is discussion over and criticism against my verdict, I am satisfied with this verdict. There could not be a much better verdict on this issue. That is why I am happy. I tried to deliver the verdict in such a way that no crisis appears [in future]. I have also worked hard for this.
“I delivered verdicts on the 5th to the 13th amendments to the constitution. The people will judge what sort of verdict I have given. I have dedicated my verdicts to the country and its people. This is why I did not want to tell this way about my verdict. However, I praised three justices in the verdict.”
Retirement does not matter
Justice Khairul also gave his reaction to the debate whether a justice can write verdict after going to retirement.
“There is no illegal bar of writing verdict after a chief justice goes into retirement. In the Appellate Division, many judges wrote verdicts after their retirement. If any rule, barring the justices from writing verdicts after retirement exists, many verdicts would have been cancelled. But, there is no such rule. So a justice may finish writing his or her verdict even after going into retirement. People who raise such question are wrong. I wrote the verdict from the feeling of responsibility. No government benefit was given for writing this verdict. Lots of hard work went behind preparing the verdict. And there is a history of miseries behind writing this verdict. Whereas remuneration should have been given for writing the verdict, some people want to create debate raising the question of [my] authority.”
Justice Khairul, the 19th chief justice who retired on May 17, 2011, is passing his time at his residence. He watches movies and telefilms on the television and read stories. He informed the Dhaka Tribune that he was passing his time well. He has become a grandfather recently.