The 10th WTO Ministerial Conference in Nairobi concluded yesterday with a declaration that is considered to have ensured the interest of the least developed countries (LDCs) like Bangladesh as expected earlier.
It, however, left most contentious issues of the Doha Development Agenda (DDA) unresolved and kept them as important elements for future agenda.
Whatever progress was made in the DDA, the declaration ensured that the LDCs will be entitled to preferential rules of origin while preferential treatment in favour of services and service suppliers will be implemented to ensure increased LDC participation in services trade.
The decision on the extension of the transition period of the Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (Trips) up to 2030 for the LDCs for certain obligations with respect to pharmaceutical products as well as the related waiver decision adopted earlier was also included in the declaration.
“We shall ensure that all issues of specific interest of LDCs shall be pursued on a priority basis with a view to strengthening them, making them commercially meaningful and, when appropriate, legally binding,” reads the declaration, making a strong commitment to addressing the marginalisation of LDCs in international trade and to improving their effective participation in the multilateral trading system.
“If they can come up with something today, Bangladesh will gain,” Tofail said, after attending the heads of delegation meeting in the morning. He left the venue to take the flight home before the concluding session in the evening.
Amid claps, conference Chair Amina Mohamed made the declaration after five days of hectic negotiations that repeatedly went on the verge of collapse.
Addressing the closing session, conference chair Amina Mohamed said it will benefit developing countries, particularly the LDCs. “Of course, outstanding issues remain and we’ll have to continue to work on them,” she spoke about the contentious issue.
“The decision to eliminate agriculture export subsidy was taken to benefit the farmers of developing and least developed countries,” said DG Roberto Azevedo.
“Whatever decisions we have taken that would be the best what we could do,” he said, adding that the decisions taken here will change the lives of millions.
Some ministers were given floor to give their opinion before adopting the declaration. Few appreciated being able to reach an agreement, but Indian Trade Minister Nirmala Sitharaman expressed disappointment, saying that the decision (on agriculture subsidy) was taken without taking into consideration their points.
“I am surprised that many of the amendments we had given have not gone through,” she said, expressing disappointment. “It is completely unacceptable.”
The trade minister of Venezuela also criticised the decision process and called upon the members that the decision in the future will not be taken without hearing the majority.
Deep differences among the influential members of the WTO had virtually stalled the trade negotiation as the authorities had to continue talks for one more day yesterday.
The wide gap over agriculture issue among USA, India and Brazil had made the negotiation uncertain, a member of Bangladesh delegation told the Dhaka Tribune.
At one stage, Bangladesh Commerce Minister Tofail Ahmed said the outcome of the conference at this point has become uncertain, as a result. Until afternoon, he was not sure whether the WTO could come up with a declaration at all.
Following a meeting of heads of delegation that took place for a short while yesterday, conference Chair Amina Mohamed and WTO Director General Roberto Azevedo in their last push hurriedly convened another meeting of the countries maintaining differences over the proposal for elimination of the agriculture subsidy.
A group of civil societies networking together through the global Our World Is Not For Sale (OWINFS) yesterday protested what they said the nature of negotiations was “non-transparent and exclusive.”
They said a small five-member group known as G5 (US, EU, Brazil, India and China) is meeting behind closed doors to draft the text.
The declaration recognised those remaining issues of Doha that included major disputed areas like advancing work in all three pillars of agriculture, namely domestic support, market access and export competition, as well as non-agriculture market access, services, development, TRIPS and rules.
“Members shall also continue to give priority to the concerns and interests of least developed countries. Many Members want to carry out the work on the basis of the Doha structure, while some want to explore new architectures,” says the declaration.
Protesters demonstrated at the entrance of the conference venue holding signs and chanting “Where is Africa in G5?”, “Where is LDCs in G5?”, “Reject G5 Texts!”, “Reject backroom deals!”, and “No Take it or Leave it Text.”
They pointed out outrageousness of rich countries to abandon the so-called “Development Round” while excluding LDCs and Africans from the discussions.
The minister, who is the coordinator for the LDCs, said it would be unfortunate, however, for some of our cotton-producing (LDCs) group members - they have been deprived of what we wanted for them as a group.
“We had come here with much hope that we’ll get a final decision on implementation of the measures taken in Doha, Bali and Hong Kong. But it was not fulfilled.”
Other members did not reaffirm the Doha mandates, as they believe new approaches are necessary to achieve meaningful outcomes in multilateral negotiations,” says the declaration.
The LDCs in their common ministerial declaration had urged the members to fast-track the resolution of the cotton issue for eliminating all trade distorting policies affecting the sector.
Mali, Burkina Faso, Chad, and Benin, with many farmers who depend on cotton for their livelihoods, have for many years been arguing against US subsidies to its industrial cotton farmers.
US cotton is made cheaper than cotton from West Africa, undercutting income by many millions, but no progress has been made on this issue at the Nairobi talks.
“The US is against the issue. That’s why things are not moving,” a member of Chad delegation told the Dhaka Tribune on the sidelines of the conference.
Executive Director of ActionAid USA Marie Clarke, who is on the ground, said the unfair subsidies given by the US to a relatively small number of cotton farmers have pushed desperately poor families in other parts of the world into deep poverty.
“New laws in the US would even remove the few restrictions on these subsidies,” she said. It is a moral outrage that the world’s richest country will continue to sacrifice African farmers for the sake of a relatively small number of wealthy cotton farmers.”
In a press release, ActionAid also said: “By taking no position on the ‘Doha Development Agenda,’ we can now expect the question to be thrown to the lawyers. And we know that whoever has the most lawyers usually wins. But in either case, there has been no forward movement in Nairobi on reducing inequality between nations in global trade.”