Clemency only option now

Condemned for committing crimes against humanity including genocide in 1971, notorious war criminals Ali Ahsan Mohammad Mujahid and Salauddin Quader Chowdhury are now left with one option to save themselves: seeking presidential clemency.

In that case, they will have to admit the crimes proved against them at the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court.

If rejected, the government will execute the death-row convicts by hanging them from the neck, as ordered by the International Crimes Tribunal.

The process began yesterday after the top court bench of Chief Justice Surendra Kumar Sinha rejected two review petitions filed by the convicts seeking acquittal. “Dismissed … both are dismissed,” the chief justice pronounced.

The bench heard Mujahid’s case on Tuesday and Salauddin’s case yesterday.

After the top court verdict, war crimes trial campaigners brought out victory processions in Dhaka and some other parts of the country.

On the other hand, Jamaat-e-Islami called a dawn-to-dusk hartal for today in protest against the death sentence of Mujahid, the party’s secretary general. After holding a brief procession in Moghbazar, party leaders demanded release of Mujahid and all Jamaat leaders.

Security measures were beefed up across the country to thwart untoward incidents as the members of Jamaat and its radical student front Islami Chhatra Shibir had resorted to massive violence following verdicts in the past couple of years.

Both the convicts were kept at Dhaka Central Jail yesterday. They have been in jail since 2010.

During the review hearing, Mujahid’s lawyer argued that the Jamaat leader could not be held responsible for the crimes al-Badr had committed in 1971, and also claimed that the witnesses and evidence were not adequate to give him death sentence.

The prosecution argued that Mujahid had full authority over al-Badr, a notorious militia force formed with members of Islami Chhatra Sangha that had carried out systematic abduction and killing of intellectuals.

Mohammadpur’s Physical Training Institute was used as an army camp during the war where al-Badr established its headquarters. Witnesses said that they had seen Mujahid along with other Jamaat and Chhatra Sangha leaders including Ghulam Azam and Motiur Rahman Nizami.

Mujahid, now 69, had always instigated, actively suggested, intentionally aided and supported his al-Badr force for the commission of brutal killings in the name of Islam and defence of United Pakistan. He also instigated his fellows to kill the freedom fighters addressing them as miscreants, agents of India, dogs and traitors.

He was also given death for the murder of nine Hindu civilians in Faridpur.

Meanwhile, former BNP lawmaker Salauddin’s counsel argued that he had been in Pakistan during the war, and therefore, the charges brought against him were baseless.

But in the judgements, both the tribunal and the Appellate Division mentioned that Salauddin had left the country in late September, after being injured in an attack launched by the freedom fighters in Chittagong. He was given death for the murders of Nutan Chandra Singha, Sheikh Mozaffar and Sheikh Alamgir, and genocides in Unosottor Para, Banik Para and Madhya Gohira.

Salauddin, now 66, and his father, Convention Muslim League leader Fazlul Quader Chowdhury, converted their Goods Hill residence into a torture cell.

The apex court started hearing Salauddin’s review plea around 9:10am yesterday. It lasted for more than an hour.

During the hearing, the court found that the defence documents claiming that the convict had been studying at a Punjab University in 1971 were acceptable. There were a lot of anomalies in the certificates signed by a professor.

The defence claimed that Salauddin had gone to Pakistan on March 29, 1971 for study and returned in 1974.

A six-time lawmaker from Raozan of Chittagong, Salauddin was given capital punishment for committing murders and torture of freedom fighters and local Hindus. On the other hand, Mujahid was sentenced to death for masterminding the abduction and murders of intellectuals at the fag end of war.

After the verdicts Khandker Mahbub Hossain, chief counsel of Mujahid and Salauddin, said that no one could refute the verdict coming from the Appellate Division. “A lawyer does not support a criminal … I have no personal reaction to express [before media]. We fought but lost.”

Asked about their next steps, he said: “It depends on the government and the convicts. The government can pardon the convicts, if it wants, or the convicts can seek presidential clemency.”

Mujahid’s son Ali Ahmed Mabrur claimed that his family had been deprived of justice. No direct allegation was brought against his father. “We will decide on filing the mercy petition within a day or two if the government allows us to meet with him.”

Attorney General Mahbubey Alam welcomed the verdict. He said: “Now there is no legal bar to the execution of the verdicts. The jail authorities will follow the government order to fix the date and time for the execution.

“This is for the first time in the country’s history that a criminal is awarded death penalty for killing the intellectuals. Through the killings, Mujahid and his al-Badr men wanted the nation to suffer after independence.”

He also said that Salauddin had been a terror in his area in 1971.

Asked if the jail authorities needed the short order to execute the convicts, he replied in the negative, saying that there was no stay order against the verdict. “As the review petitions were rejected, the death warrants issued by the tribunal have now become effective,” he added.

In the full verdict published on October 1, the judges said that Mujahid along with some other members of his force had rushed to the cantonment and met with the high officials of the Pakistan Army, on the morning of December 16, 1971 and demanded arms for fighting against the freedom fighters, though the Pakistan Army had already decided to surrender.

“...It will be a mockery of justice to permit the accused to escape the extreme penalty of law when faced with such evidence and such cruel acts … The sentence awarded by the tribunal for intellectuals’ killings is not disproportionate in view of the nature of charge and evidence adduced. The people of this earth did not forget Hiroshima and Nagasaki. This nation did not and shall never forget 1971,” the court said.

In the full verdict of Salauddin’s case, the top court said that he had persecuted, killed and caused disappearance of civilian people solely on religious and political grounds. He had direct involvement in the killing of innocent people.

The judges also mentioned about his behaviour during the trial at the tribunal. “He showed no repentance or remorse for his conduct at any point in time rather he neglected the process of trial. The tribunal recorded his demeanour observing that he was arrogant and violated the decorum of the tribunal by shouting off and continued such conduct throughout the process of the trial despite warnings.

So far, two war criminals have been executed after completing all legal procedures. They are Jamaat leaders Abdul Quader Molla and Muhammad Kamaruzzaman. Another death-row convict Delawar Hossain Sayedee’s sentence was commuted to life-term jail after appeal hearing. None of the three convicts sought presidential clemency.

Two more appeal cases are pending with the apex court – Motiur Rahman Nizami and Mir Quasem, both Jamaat leaders.