Indian SC rules out wholesale changes in revived judges’ appointment

The Indian Supreme Court on Tuesday ruled out wholesale changes on a judges’ appointment system, which was revived after it declared a central government-endorsed commission unconstitutional, but agreed to consider suggestions on transparency, criteria for selection of judges and setting up a secretariat for its efficient functioning.

The top court was hearing the government, bar associations and jurists to devise means to make judicial appointments transparent after it declared the National Judicial Appointments Commission (NJAC) unconstitutional.

Unanimously passed by Parliament last year, the NJAC act was to replace the decades-old collegium system under which top five Supreme Court judges select judges for the higher judiciary.

“There can’t be any wholesale change in the collegium system,” Hindustan Times quoted Justice JS Khehar, the head of the five-judge bench.

The same bench had on October 16 struck down the 99th Constitutional Amendment as unconstitutional. But three of them had criticised the opacity in the functioning of the collegium and invited suggestions to improve it.

On behalf of the government, Indian Attorney General Mukul Rohatgi said the collegium must put in public domain the minimum eligibility criteria for a person to be appointed judge and consult the bar before recommending names for appointment of judges. It should give reasons for selecting or rejecting someone’s candidature for judgeship, he said.

Rohatgi suggested that the proposed secretariat should advertise vacancies, invite applications and sift them before the collegium takes the final call.

Senior jurist Fali Nariman, who had argued against the NJAC, told the court that the collegium system was not receptive at all.

At the end of a two-hour hearing, the bench asked the parties to file written submissions compiling suggestions on transparency, eligibility criteria, establishment of a secretariat and evolving a mechanism for redressal of complaints by the collegium. The matter will be heard again on Thursday.