The government blames political unrest for poor HSC results, but academics say students could not adopt to new creative questions and teachers were not up to the mark either.
“Introduction of the creative writing system resulted in poor performance in the HSC examinations. Students failed to understand and hence properly answer the questions. The teachers were also not able to give them clear idea about the new method,” said Dr Syed Manzoorul Islam, professor of English at Dhaka University.
“Students cut a sorry figure in the exams because of weakness in the way they learn both English and Bangla languages. Their dependence on memorisation also contributed to the pass rate debacle,” the professor said.
In Dhaka board last year, when questions were not creative, an impressive 92.59% passed in English. This year, however, that has come down to 79.1%.
Students who sat for the examination under the Jessore board performed the worst in English, with only 50.91% students passing in the subject. Last year, this board’s performance was a touch better at 65.07% passing in English.
Prof Dr Syed Manzoorul Islam also blamed the coaching centres for making students over-dependent on guide books instead of making them read and understand the textbook topics. “There is also a shortage of trained teachers. Moreover, students are adopting non-academic writing styles such as the FM method.”
Asked how can this be remedied, the veteran academician said: “The government will have to concentrate on appointing quality teachers who can show students how the new system works.”
Rasheda K Choudhury, a director of the Campaign for Popular Education, told the Dhaka Tribune: “This year’s poor results should not be considered a distress. Ups and downs are common in case of results.”
She also said: “Students in the rural areas perform well in PSC [Primary School Certificate] exams, but they fail to carry on with it at the HSC level because there is a shortage of trained teachers there. Science students’ grades suffer because of inadequate lab facilities.”
While talking to the Dhaka Tribune, Serajul Islam Choudhury, professor emeritus of Dhaka University, questioned the previous few years’ good results. He also said that he had confusions over how the questions are set in public examinations. Board officials said the poor results are consequences of strict scrutiny and creative questions.
They said students have failed in English on a wholesale basis and their performance is Bangla has also been poor.