The National Board of Revenue (NBR) has failed to bring a major portion of shops eligible for using Electronic Cash Register (ECR) machines under e-transaction even after half of a decade has passed since the system was made mandatory.
After its introduction, only 35% shops installed the system while many keep the system ineffective, saying the machines are out of order, said NBR officials.
They added that the ECR machines were found to be showcased in many shops.
The slow progress in introducing the e-cash register to the shops helped the shop owners get the upper hand over the taxmen and they continued avoiding VAT.
In July 2009, the NBR made it mandatory for 11 types of business to install and use ECR machine and Point of Sales (POS) software to boost VAT collection.
A huge number of shops and food centres still do not use e-register for transactions with their customers, according to the NBR data.
The businesses include hotels, restaurants, sweetmeat shops, furniture outlets, beauty parlours, community centres, all shops located at mega shopping malls in the metropolis, departmental stores, general stores, big and medium-size wholesalers and retailers at the metropolis and jewelers.
The technology was introduced to prevent evasion of VAT collected from the consumers by the shopkeepers as the manual system of accounting used at the outlets leaves room for tax evasion.
According to the NBR data available till May, only 35% shops under the 11 categories have installed either ECR or POS. Currently, around 38,000 shops are paying VAT in the country.
The NBR field offices have identified 11,005 shops eligible for using the technology, among which, 8,559 were selected for ECR installation. Of the 8,559 shops, only 2,970 have installed the mechanism, according to the NBR data.
It is, however, widely alleged that many businesses, even after ECR installations, do not use ECR while making financial transactions with the customers although they are entitled to give the printed transaction slips to their customers.
According to the section 37 of VAT Act 1991, non-compliance will be considered an offense and the NBR will take legal actions against the shops which are not using ECR or POS software.
The renowned restaurant Star Kabab is an example that issues both printed and handwritten slips. The restaurant, in most cases, delivers handwritten slips to the customers to skip the VAT collection process.
There are many more shops, restaurants and food outlets that collect VAT from consumers, but do not deposit it to the national exchequer, officials said.
Tasmia Ekram, a consumer, shared her terrible experience on July 19. She said many shopkeepers, mostly restaurants, SMEs and local retail shops deny the consumers VAT challan.
“I went to a restaurant where the total bill was Tk1644.50 including 15% VAT, which is Tk214.50,” she said, adding that when asked for the challan, the restaurant staff said it was a new restaurant that has yet to introduce the challan.
They offered the client a 10% discount instead. When the customer asked who will take the remaining 5%, the restaurant only charged Tk1,430, the original cost without VAT.
Tasmia suggested that the corporate houses along with the NBR can participate in public awareness campaign.
This is not a new incident, rather this has been a common practice across the country.
People are requested to take receipts printed through ECR from the shops, officials said, adding that the consumers can always file complaint with the NBR if they are denied slips by the shops.
NBR Chairman Md Nojibur Rahman has admitted that the progress of ECR programme was very slow as many businesses avoid using the mechanism.
“Many companies are escaping the ECR transaction intentionally, making the system ineffective. The VAT intelligence office has already detected some VAT evaders and imposed penalty on them,” he said.
The NBR boss added that there will be no revenue leakage once the VAT system goes online. The revenue authorities is set to introduce Value Added Tax and Supplementary Duty Act 2012 from July 2016.
The taxpayers will be able to submit their income tax returns online and all other processes including assessment of returns, tax calculation, payment, audit, providing tax clearance certificates will be done online once the system gets automated.