Health advocates have criticised the latest draft agreement at the COP31 climate summit, warning that it lacks the concrete commitments needed to protect public health and address the growing threats posed by climate change.
The Global Climate and Health Alliance (GCHA) has called on governments to strengthen climate finance commitments and ensure a just and equitable transition away from fossil fuels as negotiations entered their final stage on Sunday.
Representing more than 300 health professional and civil society organisations and networks worldwide, the alliance raised concerns over the latest draft cover decision, particularly its weakened language on international legal obligations, scientific evidence and fossil fuel dependence.
Jess Beagley, policy lead at GCHA, said the draft acknowledged the links between climate change and health, including the need for climate-resilient health systems and greater protection for children. However, she said this recognition was not backed by concrete commitments.
“The latest text of the cover decision clearly recognises the links between climate change and health impacts, and the need for more climate-resilient health systems, including the importance of protecting children, but there is a chasm between this brief acknowledgement and commitment to real climate action to protect health and lives,” Beagley said in a statement issued on November 22.
The alliance urged developed countries to make stronger climate finance commitments to help developing nations protect vulnerable populations from worsening climate impacts.
“The people of the world need developed countries to make strong commitments to provide climate finance that gives developing countries the resources they need to protect their populations, and to advance global progress towards a just and equitable transition away from fossil fuels,” she said.
Beagley also warned that weakening international cooperation could further endanger public health.
“Without an ongoing commitment to multilateralism people’s health will be placed at increasing risk,” she added.
Concerns over legal obligations and climate science
GCHA expressed particular concern over changes to the draft decision, including the removal of an earlier reference to the International Court of Justice (ICJ) advisory opinion on states' obligations regarding climate change.
The alliance also criticised the draft for failing to explicitly recognise the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) as a source of the best available scientific evidence to guide climate action.
According to Beagley, these omissions risk weakening the scientific and legal foundations of the proposed agreement at a time when stronger international commitments are urgently needed to tackle the climate crisis.
Carbon capture target raises health concerns
The proposed target to scale up carbon capture and storage was another major concern for the health alliance.
GCHA warned that expanding carbon capture and storage could prolong reliance on fossil fuels, potentially increasing the health risks associated with their continued production and use.
“The latest draft of the cover decision eliminates a previous reference to the ICJ Advisory Opinion on the obligations of States with respect to climate change, fails to directly recognise the IPCC as a source of the best available science to guide climate action, and includes a deeply problematic target to scale up carbon capture and storage which could lead to increased health harms on account of expanded fossil fuel dependence,” Beagley said.
The alliance issued its warning as negotiators awaited a plenary session to consider the proposed agreement, with disagreements continuing over fossil fuels, climate finance and the direction of the global energy transition.
Health advocates are urging governments to ensure that the final outcome goes beyond acknowledging climate-related health risks and includes meaningful commitments to protect lives, support developing countries and accelerate the transition away from fossil fuels.
For the global health community, the success of COP31 will be measured not only by diplomatic agreements but also by whether governments take concrete action to reduce the growing health burden of climate change.