Metro vs subway: Planners at odds

The Bridges Division's proposal to build a four-route city-wide subway system was presented at a seminar at the Shetu Bhaban on April 3. Representatives of Road Transport and Highways Division and Dhaka Transport Coordination Authority (DTCA) were present at the event.
At that seminar, Bangladesh Bridge Authority laid out a plan to build four subways across the capital and argued that they could replace the proposed elevated railway Mass Rapid Transit and the Bus Rapid Transit project. The presentation was titled “Subway is safer than Elevated Structures during Earthquake,” and a large portion of it was dedicated to reviewing how earthquakes affected elevated transport systems in other cities such as Kobe in Japan. “Underground Train is more efficient and effective mode of transport in terms of environment, social and economic reasons,” the presentation said. It outlined the problems of an elevated train, such as displacement, land acquisition, demolition, reconstruction, tree cutting and environmental impact. The Bridges Division compared the costs of the Metro Rail line 6 which will begin constructing very soon, connecting Uttara and Motijheel to the first two subway routes. It showed that the MRT 6 will cost $169 million per kilometre and the subways will cost $195 million per kilometre. The alignment of the proposed Subway 1 is almost the same as the MRT line 1, which is in the RSTP. Besides, the proposed BRT 3 and MRT 4 which is under RSTP, has a similar route with the Subway 2. DTCA Executive Director Kaikobad Hossain at that seminar opposed the plan to build subways outside the Revised Strategic Transport Plan (RSTP) in strong terms. “The government has a strategic transport plan for 20 years which is currently under revision and the revision process is almost complete,” he said. DTCA is in charge of the RSTP and has carried out a large number of surveys and feasibility studies to revise the plan. “If any authority has been planning on the transport sector it should follow the revised STP. Otherwise not a single plan will be allowed,” Kaikobad said. The director proposed ways in which the subways could be incorporated into the RSTP. “The proposed subways are not included in the RSTP. However it would be possible to build subways following the RSTP’s direction. The RSTP has already proposed four metro rails, parts of which will be underground. I think that might be completely underground in the existing alignment. “But there is no opportunity to plan a new alignment for any Mass Rapid Transit (MRT) such as metro rail or subways,” he said. Jamilur Reza Choudhury, who presided over the meeting, said, “The metro rail which will connect Uttara to Motijheel is now under construction. So we have to thinking properly before fixing the new subway route.” “Besides, most of the city’s roads are constructed in a north to south alignment. We need to give importance to making new routes connecting the east and the west part of Dhaka,” he added.