COP31 draft decision sparks criticism over retreat on fossil fuels, climate finance

The second draft of the COP31 cover decision has drawn criticism from climate campaigners and civil society representatives, who say revisions have weakened commitments on fossil fuel phase-out, climate finance, loss and damage, and the responsibilities of developed countries.

The revised text, circulated on November 19, has been described as a significant retreat from the earlier November 16 draft. Campaigners argue that it removes important accountability measures, timelines and references to international climate obligations while retaining broad political language.

They warn that the changes could undermine progress on protecting climate-vulnerable countries, particularly developing nations such as Bangladesh, which contribute relatively little to global greenhouse gas emissions but face disproportionate climate impacts.

Harjeet Singh, global convenor of the Fill the Fund campaign and founding director of the Satat Sampada Climate Foundation, said the revised draft represents a serious setback at a time when climate-vulnerable countries urgently need stronger commitments.

The changes, he argued, weaken the international response to climate change by reducing ambition on fossil fuels, adaptation finance and loss and damage.

One of the major concerns surrounding the revised text is the removal of explicit references to transitioning away from fossil fuels and the COP30 fossil fuel roadmap.

Climate campaigners argue that the omission represents a significant regression, particularly as fossil fuel combustion remains the principal driver of global warming.

The revised language has also raised concerns over references to carbon capture, utilization and storage (CCUS) and carbon dioxide removal (CDR).

Advocates fear that promoting these technologies without clear commitments to reduce fossil fuel production and consumption could provide opportunities for polluters to delay meaningful emissions reductions.

They argue that technological interventions should not become substitutes for cutting greenhouse gas emissions at their source.

The revised draft has also come under scrutiny for removing an explicit reference to a $120 billion adaptation finance figure, alongside the Oxfam grant-equivalent baseline and proposed debt-pause protections.

Campaigners say the changes could weaken financial commitments to countries already struggling with the rising costs of climate adaptation.

For developing countries, climate finance is not simply an additional development resource. It is essential for protecting coastal communities, strengthening infrastructure, addressing water insecurity and responding to increasingly severe weather events.

The omission of debt-related safeguards is particularly concerning for countries that must borrow to finance climate resilience while facing mounting economic pressures from climate-related disasters.

The revised text has also raised questions about the future of the Fund for responding to Loss and Damage.

According to figures highlighted by campaigners, approximately $2.8 billion in funding requests have been submitted against allocations of around $342 million. They also point to a pledge-conversion rate of approximately 50%.

Against this backdrop, removing the push for pledging by the end of 2027 has been criticized as another indication of declining ambition.

Harjeet Singh and other campaigners argue that the gap between the financial needs of affected communities and available resources demonstrates the urgent need to strengthen the fund.

For countries such as Bangladesh, which face cyclones, coastal erosion, salinity intrusion, flooding and other climate-related hazards, inadequate loss and damage financing can translate into greater economic and humanitarian consequences.

Another major concern relates to the removal or weakening of references to Article 9.1 of the Paris Agreement and Article 2.1(c).

Article 9.1 establishes the obligation of developed countries to provide financial resources to assist developing countries with mitigation and adaptation.

Article 2.1(c), meanwhile, concerns making financial flows consistent with pathways towards low greenhouse gas emissions and climate-resilient development.

Campaigners fear that weakening references to these provisions could blur the distinction between public, grant-based climate finance and broader efforts to align financial flows with climate objectives.

They also argue that the revised text gives insufficient recognition to developed countries' historical responsibility for greenhouse gas emissions and their corresponding obligations to support vulnerable nations.

The principle of common but differentiated responsibilities and respective capabilities (CBDR-RC) remains central to international climate negotiations. However, advocates warn that removing explicit references to historical responsibility risks reducing equity to political rhetoric rather than a meaningful obligation.

The revised draft has also attracted criticism for replacing a continuing science-focused work program and an explicit commitment to return global temperatures below 1.5°C with a single dialogue at the ninth session of the Conference of the Parties serving as the meeting of the Parties to the Paris Agreement (CMA9).

Campaigners say this approach does not adequately reflect the urgency of the climate crisis, particularly as global warming and potential temperature overshoot threaten to intensify irreversible losses in vulnerable regions.

They argue that scientific assessments must remain central to negotiations and that countries need stronger mechanisms to translate climate science into concrete political commitments.

Concerns have also emerged over the proposed governance arrangements for a mechanism under negotiation.

Lidy Nacpil said the current draft does not contain options that could secure consensus while delivering meaningful progress.

She said that, among the 3 options presented in the paragraph concerning the mechanism's governance, only the third could potentially lead to progress, despite its shortcomings. However, she argued that developed countries would not agree to it.

The other 2 options, she warned, could lock countries into an ineffective mechanism.

"We urge Parties to go back to the negotiating table, engage with each other, and at the very least agree on a procedural decision that will allow negotiations to continue. At this point, no agreement is better than a bad agreement," Nacpil said.

Sharif Jamil also expressed disappointment over the revised cover decision, arguing that it reflects insufficient ambition and accountability at a time when vulnerable countries are experiencing increasingly severe climate impacts.

"The revised COP31 cover decision is deeply disappointing. At a time when vulnerable countries are facing worsening climate impacts, weakening fossil fuel commitments, scaling back adaptation finance, and failing to ensure adequate loss and damage funding reflect a troubling lack of ambition and accountability," he said.

"Once again, countries like Bangladesh, which contributed least to the climate crisis, are being left to bear its heaviest burden."

As COP31 approaches its concluding stage, the controversy over the revised cover decision highlights the continuing divide between developed and developing countries over climate responsibility, financing and the pace of the global energy transition.

For climate-vulnerable countries, the central question remains whether the final political outcome will translate commitments into adequate financial support and measurable action or leave frontline communities facing the consequences of a crisis they did little to create.

This story was produced as part of the COP31 Climate Change Media Partnership, a journalism fellowship organised by Internews' Earth Journalism Network, Informed Earth and the Stanley Center for Peace and Security.