The Appellate Division is scheduled to hear on Sunday an appeal against a High Court verdict that declared several provisions of the Fifteenth Amendment to the Constitution—including the abolition of the widely debated caretaker government system—illegal.
The hearing will take place before a bench led by Justice Zubayer Rahman Chowdhury.
Earlier, on December 11, 2025, a six-member appellate bench led by then chief justice Dr Syed Refaat Ahmed adjourned the hearing, saying it would be held after the 13th national parliamentary election.
During that hearing, lawyer Dr Sharif Bhuiyan represented the writ petitioner. Barrister Sara Hossain, Barrister Ruhul Quddus Kajal, Advocate Mohammad Shishir Monir and Barrister SM Shahriar Kabir took part in the proceedings as intervenors, while then attorney general Md Asaduzzaman appeared for the state.
On December 8, senior lawyer Dr Sharif Bhuiyan argued in favor of the application before the High Court. The lawyer for the then writ petitioner—Sujan editor Badiul Alam Majumdar—filed the application seeking the cancellation of the Fifteenth Amendment.
At one stage of the hearing, the chief justice observed, “If there are procedural defects in the Fifteenth Amendment, then it is possible to cancel the entire amendment at once.”
On December 17, 2024, the High Court declared several provisions of the Fifteenth Amendment—including the abolition of the caretaker government system—contradictory to the Constitution and illegal. It also reinstated the provision for a referendum in the Constitution.
The verdict said democracy is part of the Constitution’s basic structure and develops through free, fair and impartial elections. However, the will of the people was not reflected in the past three parliamentary elections, which led to the July mass uprising.
According to the High Court, the caretaker government system had become part of the basic structure of the Constitution. The verdict was delivered by a bench of Justice Farah Mahbub and Justice Debashish Roy Chowdhury.
The court declared Articles 20 and 21 of the Fifteenth Amendment Act—related to the abolition of the caretaker government system—void. It also analyzed 54 provisions that were added, revised and substituted through the amendment.
The High Court said the entire Fifteenth Amendment was not being canceled and left the remaining provisions to the next national parliament.
Regarding the referendum issue, the court observed that Article 142 of the Constitution—added through the Twelfth Amendment—had been repealed under the Fifteenth Amendment Act. As it was inconsistent with the Constitution’s basic structure, the court reinstated it.
The High Court also struck down Articles 7A, 7B and 44(2). Article 7A dealt with offenses such as abrogation or suspension of the Constitution, while Article 7B declared the Constitution’s fundamental provisions non-amendable. Article 44(2) imposed restrictions related to the enforcement of fundamental rights.
The full verdict was published in 139 pages after being signed by the High Court bench.
An appeal petition was filed on November 3. Lawyer Dr Sharif Bhuiyan filed the appeal on behalf of Sujan editor Badiul Alam Majumdar, the writ petitioner. The Supreme Court granted leave to appeal on November 13.
Sunday’s hearing has been included in the cause list of the appeal.