The recent directive empowering Deputy Commissioners to oversee development projects funded by the Annual Development Program (ADP) at the district level has led to an outcry from engineers and other officials.
Engineers organized human chains on Thursday at the premises of every centre and sub-centre of the Institution of Engineers, Bangladesh (IEB) across the country to protest the government directives.
They said the move was an anti-development step which would unnecessarily lengthen the development project implementation timeline.
Several sources said that at present engineers were controlling development projects monopoly at the field level. However, bureaucrats too wanted to take part in the process. That is why the new directives had been issued.
Shahadat Hossain Shiblu, general secretary of IEB, said that an oversight of engineering works by non-engineer professionals was disrespectful. “To open a separate office to conduct observation and evaluation is unnecessary.”
"There is still a process of evaluating and monitoring project works under the planning ministry. Engineers are accountable to the planning ministry's Implementation Monitoring and Evaluation Division (IMED),” told Shahadat.
Sources at the Public Administration Ministry said this directive had been issued at the request of the IMED.
Minister defends the decision
State Minister for Planning Dr Shamsul Alam does not see anything wrong with the directive, claiming it would ensure better monitoring and transparency.
He said: “There is nothing derogatory in sharing project data. Information sharing will increase accountability and boost a quick implementation of the development project.”
The state minister, a former bureaucrat, told Dhaka Tribune: “This directive is not creating any new layer in the district administration.”
Engineers predict further chaos
When contacted, Engineer Md Abdus Sabur, Science and Technology Affairs secretary of the Awami League and former president of the IEB, said: “In developed countries, there is no interference in the technical committees. I think a quarter of the bureaucracy, who are against development, is behind this directive.”
Addressing the concerns of the higher grade engineers in the bureaucratic process, IEB’s Services and Welfare Committee Chairman and Vice President SM Manjurul Haque Manju said: “We are not slaves of the bureaucratic system but servants of the country,”
They claimed junior grade officers in the public administration structure, such as assistant commissioners, often misbehaved with higher grade engineers.
“If the order stays, it will create further chaos. There is a need for technical and professional, knowledgeable and experienced engineers to implement development projects”, said SM Manjurul.
Generally, the projects of engineering offices are implemented under the leadership of executive engineers. Additional chief engineers and caretaker engineers do the observation and evaluation directly. The Monitoring and Evaluation Department of the planning ministry also conducts observation and evaluation on a regular basis.
Around 1,500 projects under the ADP, worth Tk2,25,324 crore, were approved for the ongoing fiscal year.
On January 18, the public administration ministry asked the DCs to open a wing under an additional deputy commissioner for monitoring and evaluating development projects and sending reports to the IMED.
This directive came into effect when DCs, during their annual conference this year, also proposed that they be given the power to oversee project implementation in their respective districts through the creation of a separate wing.
However, Planning Minister MA Mannan, turned down the proposal at the time.
However, the directive was issued the same day.
Prime Minister's Economic Affairs Adviser Dr Mashiur Rahman mentioned after the conference that there were some big projects which crossed several districts. Therefore, it would be difficult to oversee the projects under DCs with their own inspection committees.