In the almost two years since the High Court ordered the government to enforce a ban on single-use plastic in the coastal areas of the country, the Department of Environment (DoE) has been unable to take any effective measures to enforce the ban.
The court issued the order and made the DoE the main body responsible for implementing it in response to public interest litigation by the Bangladesh Environment Lawyers Association (BELA) in January 2020.
According to a 2021 study by the Environment and Social Development Organization (ESDO), the country produces around 87,000 tons of single-use plastic waste annually, and 86% of the waste is dumped in landfills.
The cabinet on June 21 issued directives on the implementation of the plastic ban in 12 coastal districts and some parts of Chittagong city in the first phase from July to December 2021. Under the directive, the DoE was supposed to ban single-use plastics on all passenger and cargo vessels, flights and at sea beach areas in the selected areas, but no initiative has been implemented in this regard.
Aim to make plastic-free coastal belt in three years
The Water Resources Planning Organisation (WARPO) suggested 40 upazilas of 12 districts and eight areas of Chittagong City Corporation in the first phase of the project to implement the ban.
The twelve districts are Bagerhat, Barguna, Bhola, Chittagong, Cox’s Bazar, Feni, Khulna, Lakshmipur, Noakhali, Patuakhali, Pirojpour and Satkhira.
A total of seven upazilas were selected from each of Bhola and Cox’s Bazar, while five were selected from each of the other districts.
The parts of the Chittagong City Corporation to be included in the project are Chittagong port, Double Mooring, Pahartali, Panchlaish, Patenga, Halishahar, Kotowali and Bayezid Bostami.
In the first year, the DoE was supposed to ban single-use plastics such as cutlery, straws, Styrofoam food packaging, and coffee stirrers from the inland transport system and beach area.
The ban would be implemented on a trial basis at hotels and restaurants of the coastal area in the first half of 2022, whereas public places such as kitchen markets, bus stands, government offices, and educational institutions would follow suit from the second half of the year.
In the third year, DoE wants to implement the ban in all the upazilas and districts on the coastal belt.
A man and a woman sorts out plastic bottles after they are collected from roadsides and garbage bins Syed Zakir Hossain/Dhaka Tribune
Despite the ambitious plan, the DoE is yet to lay any of the groundwork to implement it almost a year in. The roadmap of the plan was supposed to be fixed following an inter-ministerial meeting that is yet to be held.
According to a DoE official, a technical working group meeting consisting of brand owners, NGOs, plastic producers, and environmental groups was supposed to take place on December 5, but it was postponed.
Dr Abdullah Al Mamun, deputy director of waste and chemicals management of the DoE, said the DoE was moving with caution this time so that the ban did not fail like the previous polyethene ban.
In 2002, the government imposed a ban on producing, importing, exporting and selling polythene bags. However, the directive never turned into reality. The law has been amended multiple times since then to relax restrictions for packaged food products, sugar mills, the tea industry and some other businesses.
“Single-use plastic is a huge industry in Bangladesh. We can’t enforce anything by snatching away livelihoods. We all know what happened with the polythene ban, and we don’t want a repetition of that. When a commodity like plastic is banned, people need alternatives to replace it, and I’m afraid these are still not accessible to common people,” the DoE official added.
When asked whether the DoE would be able to reach its target to eliminate plastics from the coastal belt by 2023, the official seemed positive.
“We have lagged behind by a few steps this year, but we will catch up in the next two years,” he said.
Stakeholders not prepared
In the span of three years, the DoE aims to draft laws regarding solid waste management, prepare a guideline regarding Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR), and train people regarding waste collection and remission in the coastal area.
As the EPR falls largely on the plastic producers, it is an established practice in the European Union to make producers liable for the damage they cause to the environment.
Shamim Ahmed, president of the Bangladesh Plastic Goods Manufacturers and Exporters Association (BPGMEA), said the EPR would only be appreciated if the DoE could impose it on all companies.
“We are mass producers of plastic products, and our buyers are big corporations like Coca Cola, Nestle and other conglomerates. If the DoE wants to implement EPR, they have to charge these big conglomerates too, because they’re doing business with the plastics on a large scale,” he said.
Moreover, he said a ban would not be effective if the people are not ready to accept it.
The district and upazila constituencies are also not prepared to implement the ban.
Shayamnagar Upazila Nirbahi Officer ANM Abuzar Gifari said that two months ago they received a letter from DoE on the single-use plastic ban but no specific directives were given to take any legal action.
“As a part of our regular work, we work on making microphone announcements and install trash bins in the tourist spots, but these are mostly activities to spread awareness. The letter didn’t mention anything about legal action, so we haven’t done anything in this regard yet,” he said.
Md Abdul Malek Mia, assistant director of DoE in Bhola, said a shortage of manpower would make it difficult to implement the ban across so many different parts of the district.
Cox Bazar Sadar UNO Milton Rai said they had adequate manpower to carry out such directives, but they had not received any notice to ban single-use plastics at hotels and restaurants yet.