In a questionable move, the Bangla service of the British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) has resorted to republishing on social media a number of older “negative” news reports dating back to June 20 this year.
As a result of the mechanism called “boosting,” BBC Bangla’s most read reports for the past few days are the older ones.
Usually, a netizen considers any news shared on social media as something latest. Without caring about the time and date of publication, social media users enter the article or report shared, and go through that.
A glimpse at BBC Bangla’s Facebook page shows it is flooded with numerous old media reports. An investigation of a private news channel, Somoy TV, has noticed the “suspicious” practice.
The reports are making rounds on the Facebook wall as they are being boosted repeatedly on the page. Many are also sharing them on their Facebook account.
For instance, on September 21 alone, the news portal boosted 14 reports – all of them were old and negative in impression.
The reports were mainly focused on Bangladesh’s economic crisis and public suffering.
Experts say any news report usually does not carry importance or significance two-three months after a particular event or incident they are based on, because news is considered a “perishable commodity.”
The republication of old news impacts the commoners, and they suspect BBC Bangla might have a motive.
1. The date of publishing of the reports (translated in English) boosted on September 21 are as follows:
2. How much electricity will be saved if shops are shut at 8pm? (June 20)
3. Medicines keep getting pricier, common people under pressure (July 18)
4. Bangladesh’s energy crisis may drag on till winter (Jul 19)
5. What does PetroBangla say about gas crisis, how long does it continue? (July 21)
6. How much pressure is Bangladesh facing with forex deserve, where is the situation headed for? (July 23)
7. What impacts will the agriculture sector have upon fertilizer factory closure in Bangladesh? (July 24)
8. Bangladesh’s electricity crisis may continue this year (July 24)
9. New rules set for savings certificate sales, move to control grips (July 30)
10. ‘Can’t even feed my child an egg despite my will’ (August 3)
11. Seven strategies that may help cope with price hike (August 11)
12. Low-income people slash protein amid commodity price hike (August 16)
Job-holders careful about spending, lowering living costs (August 17)
13. Living cost: Is there any way to overcome criris? (August 22)
14. Which sector gives highest pay to workers in Bangladesh (September 1)
Experts’ take
Boosting or resharing news reports has been a trend in “new media,” according to Sheikh Mohammad Shafiul Islam, professor of journalism at the Green University of Bangladesh.
“Our mainstream media is no exception in this regard as boosting or resharing contents help earn more revenue,” he told Somoy TV.
But the page admins or managers must keep in mind that it is not an ideal practice to circulate or promote one-sided or motivated reports, he suggested.
Senior journalist Quddus Afrad finds the practice to be contrary to ethical journalism.
“BBC Bangla does have the right to boost its reports. However, the reports it is boosting seem to be motivated and their target is clear,” he observed.
He feared if BBC Bangla did it all upon a contract with someone or an organization, it would definitely harm the media outlet and negatively impact mass media as a whole.
Shafiul Islam said BBC Bangla must consider the country’s political atmosphere before the next general election.
“They should remember that news reports must not negatively impact public opinion. Entertaining readers with older news on negative issues, to increase popularity and revenue is not accepted at all,” he opined.
The academic suggested reposting and boosting all sorts of news reports as they describe a government's positive and negative activities.
“We’ve noticed that international media outlets have many motives, which they should give up,” Shafiul concluded.
When contacted by the TV channel, BBC Bangla Dhaka Bureau Editor Waliur Rahman Miraz declined to comment on the issue.
But following his suggestion, Somoy TV emailed a senior communication specialist of the BBC on Tuesday afternoon – but there was no response till 11pm.