Budget charts path in world marred by war and pandemic

After two back-to-back Covid-era budgets, Finance Minister AHM Mustafa Kamal yesterday proposed a budget intended to navigate a world disrupted by pandemic and war.

In the 51st national budget, the government has focused on maintaining macroeconomic stability and bolstering the foreign reserve.

Moreover, in order to attract investment, sustain the growth of export earnings, and safeguard marginalized people, the government came up with a set of tax cuts for businesses, a widened social safety net and a consciously modest target for revenue officials.

The finance minister presented a budget of Tk678,000 crore for FY2022-23 with the challenge of reversing the lost pace of development brought on by Covid-19 and the Ukraine conflict.

The budget’s projected average inflation rate of 5.6% for the next fiscal year seems too optimistic – perhaps even unrealistic – given the current inflationary pressures and shifting global economic factors.


Six challenges

The finance minister enumerated six major challenges for the next fiscal year while placing the national budget for FY23.

The challenges are containing inflation and enhancing domestic investment, financing additional subsidy required for the increased price of gas, power and fertiliser in international markets, utilising funds available through foreign assistance and ensuring timely completion of high priority projects of ministries and divisions, and ensuring timely completion of projects in the education and health sectors.

The challenges also include increasing collection of local Value Added Tax and raising the number of individual taxpayers, maintaining stability in the exchange rate of the Taka and keeping foreign exchange reserves at a comfortable level.

“We have to be very pragmatic in addressing six major challenges for the next fiscal year as any failure to address them properly may destabilise the macroeconomic stability,” the minister said.

“Our major strategy would be to enhance the supply while reducing the growth in demand. Therefore, import-dependent and less important government expenditures will be stopped or reduced,” he added.

The FY2022-23 budget is not just a map out of the challenging inflationary terrain of the Covid-19 and Ukraine war era. It is also a budget with an eye on a coming election year, and restoring the pace of Bangladesh’s growth is certainly part of the focus.

Finance Minister AHM Mustafa Kamal said that a priority of this year’s budget would be to improve the livelihood of people at all levels, continue with uninterrupted economic development and employment generation, and contain inflation.

The government is determined to support businesses.

How will it be paid for?

The government has to fund over a third of its outlay from foreign and domestic loans and foreign grants. The finance minister told parliament yesterday that he would be looking to make up at least a third of the Tk2,14,681 crore deficit with bank loans. 

The deficit of the budget is estimated at Tk2,41,793 crore. The government plans to take Tk1,06,334 crore from the banking sector to fill the deficit.

Besides, the government planned to borrow Tk35,000 crore from savings certificates and Tk5,001 crore from other sectors.

The finance minister decided to increase the National Board of Revenue’s (NBR) tax revenue target to Tk3,70,000 and the non-tax revenue target was proposed at Tk63,000 crore.

The projection for the GDP of this budget set at 7.5%, which was 0.25% more than the last fiscal year.

The ceiling for tax-free income has been set at Tk3,00,000, same as in the previous budget.

Moreover, the expenditure on education and health did not increase as per expectations.

Recognizing the government’s limitations in revenue generation, the minister acknowledged that although a large section of the population can afford to pay taxes, they do not, which is why the number of taxpayers is currently a little over 2.5 million in a country of 170 million people.

Inflation

Finance Minister AHM Mustafa Kamal estimated that the average inflation rate will be 5.6% in the next fiscal year.

“The government is committed to containing the rising trend of inflation by addressing inconsistencies between supply and demand. Although it remained under control until the first quarter of this year, there has been a recent spike, mainly due to external and some internal factors,” said the minister.

Zahid Hussain, former lead economist of the World Bank Dhaka Office, said of the budget and the projected inflation rate: “Inflation at 5.6% is unrealistic.”

He added: “The budget needed to place maximum emphasis on macro stability. However, the question remains as to how much it will be possible. There are two main areas. One is inflation. Increasing subsidies on food, fertilizer and electricity will generally benefit everyone.

“Second, a number of initiatives have been taken to find a way out of the dollar crisis. Let's see how effective it is.”

Proposed tax cuts

Intent on growing the economy following more than a year of reduced economic activity due to the pandemic, the finance minister proposed several tax reduction measures.

Companies not listed in the stock market will see their tax reduced to 27.5% from 30%. The tax rates for companies listed in the stock market and banks, insurance companies and financial institutions will be unchanged at 37.5%.

The finance minister said the continuation of this policy had relieved taxpayers of a huge burden and also generated investment and created employment opportunities in the country.

And, yesterday, he proposed that the tax rate for publicly traded companies will be unchanged at 22.5%.

The tax reduction for one-person company (OPC) was proposed to be lowered to 22.5% from the existing 25%.  

The businessman-turned-finance minister said the present ratio of private investment to GDP stands at 23%.

“The government has taken initiatives to improve this ratio. Reduction in corporate tax rate is expected to facilitate achieving the target for private investment to GDP ratio,” he said.

Support for exporters

In order to enhance the foreign reserve by bringing in more export earnings and remittances, the government came up with a set of benefits for export-oriented industries and expatriates.

The government has proposed slashing source tax on supplies of raw materials to manufacturers from 7% to 4% to reduce production costs in the proposed budget for FY2022-23.

Moreover, the source tax rate on supplies of trading goods has been reduced to 5% from 7% and on supplies of books except those by the government to 3% from 7%.

The government has extended the duration for textile millers to enjoy a reduced 15% corporate tax for the next three fiscal years, until June 30, 2025.

To encourage diversification of export goods and ensure a level playing field for all of the export industry, the budget proposes to introduce a 12% tax for all non-apparel goods and services exporters.

The finance minister also proposed a 10% corporate tax for all other green industries exporting goods and services.

Enhancing dollar inflows

The ongoing incentive of 2.5% will continue on remittances.

Moreover, to increase the foreign reserve, the budget has proposed to give an opportunity to legalize laundered money and assets sent abroad.

Once the money is legalized through proposed taxes, no authority including the income tax authorities, will be able to question its legitimacy.

Kamal proposed a 15% tax on immovable property repatriated to Bangladesh, 10% tax on movable property repatriated to Bangladesh and 7% tax on cash and cash equivalents repatriated to the country.

The opportunity will be in force starting from the first day of the new fiscal year and will end on June 30 next year.

Economist Zahid Hussain said of the proposed measure: “There is at best a weak incentive to declare and pay, especially for those who have already figured out how to game the system in the destination countries.

“Such activity will get them some certification, giving legitimacy to the illicit transfers made in the past.”

Moreover, the budget has proposed to withdraw the existing advance tax on gold imports to stop gold smuggling. 

Expansion of safety net coverage

The present government has been consistently increasing social safety net allocation to improve the condition of the poor. In FY2008-2009, the allocation for the social safety net was Tk13,845 crore.

Finance minister suggested allocating a total of Tk 1,13,576 crore, up from Tk 1,07,614 crore in the last fiscal year.

The proposed allocation is 16.75% of the total budget.

For the fiscal year 2022-23, the proposed increasing the allocation for social safety net programs carried out by the government to 5.5%

“We have introduced sales through TCB so that the low-income people of the country can buy daily necessities at lower prices. In addition, a significant portion of the poor has been brought under the social security programmes,” the finance minister added.

However, Professor Mustafizir Rahman, a distinguished fellow of the Center for Policy Dialogue, a think-tank,  said that even though the budget talks about the middle class, there is a lack of clear guidance on how much it is actually focused on.

“I think there was a need to focus more on fiscal policy than monitoring policy. It was necessary to give more security to the marginalized people by fixing the policy. Moreover, there is a huge deficit in this budget. Fulfilling that will put a lot of pressure on the banking sector,” he said.

Subsidies

The government is going to increase the allocation for subsidy and incentive expenditure in the budget of FY2022-2023.

The expenditure has been increased by Tk15,920 crore to Tk82,745 crore, which is 1.9% of the country’s GDP.

In preparing the budget for the next fiscal year, top priority has been given to containing inflation stemming from the fallout from the Covid-19 pandemic and the Russia-Ukraine conflict.