Rice Drive: Ad hocism won’t do, routine work needed

A nationwide anti-hoarding drive and fining of errant rice traders for law breaches have hogged the headlines for the best part of last week. The intention and the determination for this apparent crackdown on a dishonest section of commodity traders is quite clear – giving hard-pressed consumers some respite from high price shocks. But where were these food officials when it came to routine monitoring of the rice market over the course of the year? A much-needed demonstration of the recent zeal for fighting deep-seated irregularities in the rice value chain has long been absent.  

The country’s commodity laws and anti-hoarding regulations all mandate food officials to keep a constant vigil on traders, who have taken licenses from them to do food business. By definition of their job profiles, the food officials are bound to keep track of the volume of paddy being purchased by traders from the farmers – either directly or through intermediaries (farias, beparis) – in any given harvesting season, the volume of paddy being converted to rice by millers, and duration of hoarding and their subsequent transmissions to aratdars, commission agents, wholesalers and retailers down the rice value chain. 

The laws of the land demand that a license-holding rice miller submit reports to food officials concerned on a fortnightly basis on how much paddy and/or rice his/her mill has got in hand in that given period of time. For instance, an auto-rice mill owner is legally permitted to hoard for a month a volume of paddy equivalent to five times his fortnightly milling capacity and can keep in storage the milled rice (up to two times of milling capacity) for 15 days. Similarly, a wholesaler is permitted to keep a maximum stock of 300 tons of rice for a month. 

The government has an army of food officials working for it, starting from a director general in Dhaka to regional food controllers in divisions and district food controllers and staff working under their command. Their mandate is to see which errant traders are not submitting the fortnightly trade volume updates and who are the ones hoarding the food grain beyond their lawfully mandated volumes.

Unfortunately, this round-the-year market monitoring exercise is largely absent. Millers, wholesalers, and other intermediaries have been taking full advantage of the slack for years. The obvious result is that consumers in Bangladesh, who today depend on rice for over half of their calorie intake, are paying through the nose for the staple. 

On the other hand, the government is riding on an ad hoc mechanism of taming the volatile market, which has long been left unregulated.  

Solution lies with facilitating, not punishing

Rice mills are the most important link in Bangladesh’s rice value chain. Mills buy paddy from farmers and process it into rice. The dominant rice value chain is the traditional one in which the millers produce rice for the bulk market. The flow of rice to consumers takes place through market intermediaries or different value chain actors, such as farias, beparis, millers, aratdars, commission agents, wholesalers and retailers.

All of these actors in the rice value chain play crucial roles in bringing in food from field to fork. Since millers conduct milling operations throughout the year, they procure paddy mostly during the harvest season when price is low and use those as inputs to continue milling activities for several months until the next harvest takes place. There is a widespread belief that millers store rice as a tool to make windfall gains through manipulation of the market by creating a shortage. The government has its regulation on maximum storage practice for essential food grains. The regulation basically states how much grain/food a trader can store and for how long. 

The government and its Food Department are supposed to monitor and facilitate the process so that the rice market behaves. But punishing all and sundry under one special drive can’t solve the problem. Rather, it will cause more panic. 

TV footage of traders leaving their shops hurriedly in fear of raids will never augur well as far as public assurance is concerned. If panicky consumers start over-buying rice for future stocks at the household level, it will further escalate the price and the government will not be able to conduct raids at each and every house. It is never going to work. 

However, if the government makes sure its army of food officials at the grassroots do their duty with diligence and carry out their routine job properly, then it will have a lasting impact on the market.  

Finding a villain who is not there

In a rush to bring rice prices under control, food officials are now trying to find a villain who is not there. Accusing the companies selling quality rice in packets, in superstores and other high-end shops will in no way advance the cause of the government’s newfound crusade against hoarders.

In case of any specific allegation against any specific company for hoarding any large volume rice, the laws of the land can definitely take their due course. But wholescale accusations against companies that are feeding the market with quality rice will serve no purpose except further creating panic in an already volatile rice market.

When it comes to price, they are the ones keeping premium prices from the consumers – which if too exorbitant the government can always revisit, review, and ask the businesses to feed the market with packet rice at “rational” prices. But any wholesale accusation will only nip a flourishing sector in the bud.

The marketeers of packet rice are to be credited for bringing in ‘traceability’ aspects of food grains in our country. A customer can trace from the inscriptions on the packets what the price is, what the production date is, what variety it is; and if needed it can also be traced from which paddy fields or from which rice mills that lot has been sourced. These are important aspects of the quality issue, which are completely missing in our otherwise, traditional open bazaars.