‘We want a win-win situation’

DT: Criticism is pouring down on the draft regulation both from home and abroad. What is your reaction to that?

BTRC chairman: I can assure you that the main purpose of the regulation is not to muzzle public opinion on the internet. We want to put an end to three things in particular. Firstly, defamatory comments or writings against anyone. Secondly, hurting religious sentiments and finally, spreading anti-state or hate speech. Some of the laws of our land have a remedy for these offences already. We are just bringing these under a regulation.

We have prepared the regulation upon a court order. If there had been  no court order, we would have formulated this anyway. The court order made it easy to take the initiative.

DT: Social media giants have also expressed their concerns. You have said earlier that BTRC has held a meeting with some of them over the issue. Did that yield any result?

BTRC chairman: We have held several meetings. Now, we are holding meetings with Facebook and YouTube every three months. We have proposed signing an agreement. They are going over the proposal now.

Normally, when we request them to delete any content, they place that before their legal panel. They remove contents or keep them as they are as per their community standard. These contents are circulated in our country. So, you need to scrutinize them through our law. We are bargaining with them on this right now.

DT: Are they willing to listen to you?

BTRC chairman: Facebook agrees with us in principle. Also, YouTube agreed verbally. Now we are working to reach an agreement with them in writing.

DT: When will the agreement be signed?

BTRC Chairman: Before we sign the agreement, we need to finalize the regulation first. We have sent the draft regulation already to let them know what we are going to do. If we do it [finalizing draft on social media regulation] without consulting with them, they will probably not agree to comply in future.

The same thing happened in India. They have formulated regulations for the social media, internet and OTT but the social media giants are not complying with them because India did not consult them first hand.

DT: But BTRC’s one has similarities with the Indian regulation…

BTRC Chairman: Not only India, we have taken ideas from Thailand and Sri Lanka and rearranged them in our country’s context. So, there are some similarities. But the difference is, we're sitting with them and asking them to give their opinion in the initial stage.

They have already submitted their opinion. Our expert committee will now decide how much we can accommodate. Then we will share it back with them again.

DT: Are their opinions contradictory with the draft regulations?     

BTRC chairman: They have some objections. In some places they are afraid that their business will be hampered. For example, we told them that you have to provide us with the identity of the person who originated the content on social media. They don’t want to do that.

We had asked the companies to get registration in Bangladesh if they wanted to do business and they complied. Facebook, YouTube, Netflix, and Amazon have registered with the NBR and are paying VAT. We also asked them about business authentication. If you want to do ICT business you need to be registered with the BTRC as well.

We will sign the agreement I mentioned earlier before starting the registration process. I want to tell the companies to come to us and we will give them registration with some conditions.

DT: What about Messenger services having some objections on providing information about encrypted messages?

BTRC chairman: Yes. We have talked about that as well. We want a win-win situation. If we formulate a law and they do not obey, there is no benefit in doing it. We are trying to convince them to obey our rules and regulations.

DT:Social media giants are concerned about the provision of keeping residence compliance officers who can be prosecuted if the company does not comply with any government order. What is your take on this?

BTRC chairman: If they open an office and appoint people to look after their business then that will not help because contents are regulated from abroad. They have argued that if there is a compliance officer and any social media user gets offended by any content and does not get remedy, the user may physically assault him if he knows about his whereabouts.

They proposed that we contact the content regulation managers online to get any content removed. So, we asked them to sign a deal which will clearly state what compliances they are bound to do and what we will do for them.

DT: Can a settlement be done finally with the social media giants? What do you think?

BTRC chairman:  They must compromise on certain things and we will do our part. Let’s see.

DT: Rights organizations are saying that the regulation will open the scope for harassment to the descending voices. Basically, there are trust issues. How will you explain this?

BTRC chairman: All depends on implementation. We need regulation to provide justice and fair implementation depends on many things.

DT: What’s next?

BTRC chairman:  We have submitted the draft to the High Court. The court has asked us to take stakeholders’ opinions. Now we will submit an analysis on the stakeholders’ comments. After that it will be forwarded to the law ministry. It will take time.

DT: Will there be any change to the regulation?

BTRC chairman: We will bring about some changes and at the same time there is a negotiation process going on with the social media platforms. We may not accept all of their demands and the interests of our country must be protected first. In that case they have to accept certain things.

For example, we may take six of their ten suggestions. This will be a win-win situation. We hope there will be a positive outcome from the negotiation by May this year.