Padma Bridge rail link: Can the design flaw be fixed soon?

Although Bangladesh Railway (BR) and the Bangladesh Bridge Authority (BBA) initially thought the design fault in the Padma Bridge Rail Link Project (PBRLP) could be fixed within a very short time, reality says it will not. 

With the existing design, the railroad would obstruct traffic movement on the approach roads to the Padma Bridge at both ends -- Mawa and Janjira.

On Thursday, after visiting both ends of the two projects -- Padma Multipurpose Bridge Project (PMBP) and PBRLP -- officials realized that remodelling of the design is a must.

Accompanied by several high officials, Planning Minister MA Mannan and Railways Minister Nurul Islam Sujan visited the sites, stressing the importance of the much-hyped projects and to expedite the effort to get a fresh and correct design to address the issue. 

The railways minister, however, said the problem identified by the bridge authority is not a major issue, nor will it be an obstacle to implementing the project.

"We are not worried about the problem as it can be fixed easily following a meeting of the interface committee while the project work is still on," he said.

Sujan expressed optimism that trains will run on the Mawa-Bhanga portion by December 2021 when the Padma Bridge is opened for traffic.

Planning Minister Mannan said it is important to ensure a decent coordination between the railway and bridge authorities to fix the problem immediately.

Mohammad Shafiqul Islam, Padma Bridge project director, said: "We have already detailed our observation in a letter sent to the Bangladesh Railway."

Mentioning design faults of the rail link project at two crossing points, the letter stressed that those should be fixed soon.

What is the problem in design?

According to the Bridges Division, the height of the railroad was set at 4.8m and 5.2m at Mawa and Janjira respectively, the crossing points of the two projects, instead of the standard height of 5.7m. 

Furthermore, the width of the rail link was shown as 9.5m at Janjira and 10m at Mawa, instead of the standard 15.5m. 

However, Bangladesh Railway claimed they maintained 13.9m width clearance and 5.6m vertical clearance at Janjira point, and an 11.5m horizontal width with over 5.7m of vertical clearance at the Mawa end. 


Also Read - Experts: Padma Bridge rail link design flaw can be fixed in a week


Brig Gen Ahmed Jamiul Islam, project manager 1 (Mawa-Bhanga) of the Construction Supervision Consultant (CSC) to the PBRLP, said: "It is  notyet settled that a 15m width is a must horizontal clearance. 

"Technical solution is required so far for pier no 14 and 15 at Mawa point and pier no 25(1) and 25(2) at Janjira point," he added. 

How will the problem be fixed?

The railway and the bridge authority started holding interface committee meetings last week, but they are yet to come up with a solution.

Ahmed Jamiul said: "We are working together to fix the problem."

"We have already taken some technical initiatives following the requirement of the bridge authority," he added.

Meanwhile, the government's expert panel on the Padma Bridge project submitted a proposal to the Bridges Division with three possible solutions for the alignment fault in the rail line project last week.

Prof Shamim Z Bosunia, chairman of the expert panel, said: "The Padma Bridge is a part of the Asian Highway, so such problems in the measurements should be removed. The initial thought was to lower the Padma Bridge road to get the right height, but that is not a good solution.

"We have proposed revising the viaduct of the Padma Bridge rail link and remodelling the alignment of the project. If this method is applied, the girders of the rail link will not need to be changed," said Bosunia, a former teacher of the Civil Engineering Department of Bangladesh University of Engineering and Technology (Buet).

On September 16, the Cabinet Division directed the railway and the bridge authorities to correct the design fault issue immediately, as both PBRLP and PMBP are fast-track projects of the government.

On September 18, Railways Ministry Secretary Md Salim Reza, Bridges Division Secretary Mohammed Belayet Hossain, and the project directors, visited the sites to inspect the problem.

The projects

The Bangladesh Bridge Authority under the Bridges Division started construction work of the Padma Bridge in November 2014 and are scheduled to complete the 6.15 double-decker bridge by 2021. At a cost of Tk30,193 crore, the bridge will connect Dhaka with the southwestern part of the country. 

Recently, Road Transport and Bridges Minister Obaidul Quader said overall progress of the Padma Bridge project is over 81% now, while the main bridge has witnessed 90% completion of work so far.

Bangladesh Railway under the Railways Ministry started work on the Padma Bridge Rail Link Project in January 2016. 

The work on the 169-kilometre rail link between Dhaka and Jessore is scheduled to be completed by June 2024. 

The project will cost at least Tk39,246 crore and is being constructed in four segments -- Dhaka-Gandaria, Gandaria-Mawa, Mawa-Bhanga Junction, and Bhanga Junction-Jessore.

The rail project has seen 34% progress so far, according to the authorities.