Standoff between Pakistani judiciary and military?

In a dramatic and bold move by the chief justice of Pakistan (CJP), Gulzar Ahmed, who challenged (November 30) the country’s military over its discriminatory commercial activities on the government land, terming the actions “completely illegal”.  The CJP’s indictment came after the hearing of a petition that accused the military of abusing cantonment land.

Further, the CJP asked the propriety of the army’s discretion in running cinema and wedding halls, schools and housing which hardly met any defence-related purposes. CPJ Gulzar ordered the removal of several structures on the cantonment land, which apparently do not serve any purpose in the interest of defence as claimed by the military. These include cinemas, petrol pumps, housing societies, shopping malls and other buildings of similar nature. 

Significantly, he categorically condemned the existence of Canteen Stores Department (CSD) which is being misused as a commercial department outlet. Such a remark on part of the head of judiciary obviously hinted at the CSD HQs at Rawalpindi. The CJP also observed that it was not possible to allow the army’s illegal constructions to remain in place reasoning that if the military structures are not demolished, it would be difficult to remove other illegal constructions.  

Defence Secretary Lt Gen (retd) Mohammed Hilal Hussain, seemed completely defenceless and muted as his report was false, feeble and not convincing at all. Other than the CJP, the bench hearing the petition included Justice Qazi Mohammed Amin Ahmed and Justice Ijazul Ahsan, who were equally acerbic in their comments against the military for blatant misuse of the cantonment land. Also, the court directed the defence secretary to submit a compliance report within four weeks identifying the purposes of each piece of cantonment land.

The secretary’s faint defence that such constructions were for “strategic defence” fell flat as it failed to get the better of the judiciary which seems to be incensed with the military for sweeping violations of law to expand their personal gains. Reacting rather strongly, the CJP charged the army asserting that it was for the country’s defence, and not for doing business.  

Inferring from the CJP’s articulations on this case, it would appear that such observations are bound to demoralize the all-powerful and omnipotent Pakistan Army which mistakenly perceives that it is invincible but the recent judiciary remarks have surely put it at its place. 

Possibly, this is the first time in recent past that the judiciary has taken such a bold stand singling out the cantonment in this issue putting the Pakistani defence establishment on the backfoot.  

The civilian government, often accused of working under the diktat of the defence setup, must also be watching the developments with utmost curiosity. However, some segments in the civilian dispensation are reportedly that the judiciary has locked horns with the army as the Imran Khan government seems toothless to deal effectively either with the former or with the latter. 

Thus, the situation appears peculiar and at the end of four weeks, the country might witness some very tumultuous outcome.  As it is, the Pakistani government is besieged with multiple challenges threatening its existence including rising political adversity with enormous ferocity, downsliding of economic situation, the Afghan problem, distancing by the US treating Pakistan like pariahs etc adding to the civilian government and military’s woes making Imran’s political existence perhaps tougher than before. 

Shantanu Mukharji is a retired IPS officer, a security analyst and a former national security advisor to the prime minister of Mauritius