Dangerous skies can be found from Israel to Iraq, and from Nigeria to North Korea, and aviation experts say the path that took Malaysia Airlines Flight 17 and its 298 passengers over a war zone in eastern Ukraine was not unusual. Commercial airlines fly over hot spots all the time without incident. However, the risks are obvious, and different countries interpret protocols for overflights in various ways. US carriers are probably among the most conservative about what territory to fly over — and they were directed by the country’s Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) in April to avoid a narrow corridor over eastern Ukraine, an advisory that continues until April of next year.
Reactions from other aviation agencies to Malaysia Airlines’ second airborne tragedy in 2014 don’t necessarily clear the air, but the airline would have had ample precedent from other countries’ recent advisories to avoid eastern Ukrainian airspace. The International Air Transport Association, the airline industry’s largest global trade organization, issued a two-sentence statement just hours after the apparent downing of the aircraft: “Based on the information currently available it is believed that the airspace that the aircraft was traversing was not subject to restrictions.”
What does “not subject to restrictions” actually mean in terms of aircraft safety? “First of all, that wasn’t supposed to be a hot area by several hundred miles,” said John Goglia, former board member of the National Transportation Safety Board, the independent US agency that investigates airline accidents. Or, more simply, “Why were they flying there? Because they could,” said an inspector for the FAA, who did not want to be named. “They were doing nothing wrong. They had the permits.” Furthermore, rules that apply to one country may not apply to another. “Who knows?” the FAA official said. “Maybe the head of Malaysia spoke to Putin — every country is different.”
On April 23, the FAA issued a notice prohibiting US air carriers from operating within a narrow corridor of the region until at least April 2015. Although written in aviation jargon, the notice was clear: US airlines were to cease all flying within the specified zone, with no exceptions. By Thursday night, the FAA went even further, issuing an updated notice that expanded the no-fly area for all US airlines.
Earlier in April, the European Aviation Safety Agency (EASA) issued a warning terming the region around Simferapol in Ukraine an “unsafe situation” and advising that “consideration should be given to measures to avoid the airspace and circumnavigate.” That same month, EuroControl — the European Organization for the Safety of Air Navigation, which facilitates communication between the patchwork quilt of European air traffic control agencies — noted that “traffic in the Ukraine has reduced significantly since February 2014.”
Europe is not well known for its history of cross-border agreement and cooperation, and its aviation agencies flow in the same pattern. “It’s 51 different countries and it’s 51 different rules and it’s 51 different decisions being made,” says Joseph Miceli, president of the Airline Dispatcher Federation, with 27 years of experience at United Airlines.