The International Court of Justice (ICJ) on Wednesday rejected suits filed by the tiny Marshall Islands against the world's nuclear powers that sought to force them to do more to disarm. Though the suits failed on procedural grounds, India, Pakistan and Britain were brought to the court to answer the complaint at public hearings in April.
In its ruling in the country's case against India, the first of the three to be decided on Wednesday, the court said it had accepted Indian arguments that the ICJ, also known as the World Court, should not have jurisdiction in the case.
Judges said that while the Marshall Islands may not be satisfied with progress on nuclear disarmament, it had failed to show that it has any ongoing legal dispute with India fit for the court to adjudicate. It later rejected the Marshall Islands' suit against Pakistan on the same grounds. The third suit, against Britain, was still to be decided.
[youtube id="MMDuASm6sDs"]
The other nuclear powers, including declared powers China, France, Russia and the United States, as well as undeclared nuclear states Israel and North Korea, did not respond to the suit the islands filed last year.
The Marshall Islands, population 53,000, was the site of dozens of atomic-bomb tests by the United States after World War Two. It had argued that nuclear powers were failing to adhere to the 1970 Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons, notably by developing a new generation of "tactical" nuclear weapons.
In 1996, at the request of the UN General Assembly, the International Court of Justice issued an advisory opinion on nuclear weapons. Besides finding them probably illegal unless possibly used in self defense, it also found that countries are obliged "to pursue in good faith and bring to a conclusion negotiations leading to nuclear disarmament in all its aspects."
Sky turned blood-red
Initially in 2014, Majuro had accused nine countries of failing to comply with the 1968 nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT), which seeks to inhibit the spread of atomic bombs. But the ICJ already refused to take up cases against the other countries- China, France, Israel, North Korea, Russia and the United States, as they have not recognised the court's jurisdiction.
Israel has also never formally admitted to having nuclear weapons.
The Marshall Islands argued that by not stopping the nuclear arms race Britain, India and Pakistan had breached obligations under the treaty, even if New Delhi and Islamabad have not signed it.
At a poignant March hearing, Majuro's lawyers painted a vivid picture of the horrors caused by 67 nuclear tests notably the atolls of Bikini and Enewetak.
"Several islands in my country were vaporised and others are estimated to remain uninhabitable for thousands of years," Tony deBrum, a former Marshall Islands foreign minister, told the court.
"The entire sky turned blood-red," said deBrum, who was nine when he witnessed the blasts.
Judge Abraham noted the archipelago, "by virtue of the suffering which its people endured as a result of it being used as a site for extensive nuclear testing, has special reasons for concern about nuclear disarmament."
"But that fact does not remove the need to establish that the conditions for the court's jurisdiction are met," Abraham said.
Horrific weapons
The so-called "Operation Castle" tests in March and April 1954 were particularly devastating and resulted in massive contamination due to nuclear fall-out. The NPT commits all nuclear weapon states "to pursue negotiations in good faith on effective measures relating to cessation of the nuclear arms race at an early date."
Critics had argued however that the ICJ action was a distraction as the islanders' real fight was with Washington. They contended the case was unrelated to the victims' claims for increased compensation, better health care and clean-ups to render the sites habitable again.
The islands hoped however to reignite the debate over the disarmament talks, which have stalled over the past two decades.
"The Marshall Islands decided to bring these cases because they come from a notion that in the end nuclear weapons are the most horrific weapons on earth," said Majuro's lawyer Van den Biesen.
"That it happened this early is certainly very disappointing for them and the whole nuclear disarmament movement," said Joris Larik, senior researcher at The Hague Institute for Global Justice
"But it also shows that small island nations are looking for smart ways to play a role on the global stage. Sometimes they succeed and in a case like this, perhaps not so much."