US presidential elections: A brief history

Americans are at a crossroads today. The kind of future they wish for themselves will certainly be decided at the presidential election on November 3, if indeed everything goes according to convention and the rules of politics. For a very large number of Americans as for people around the world, it is an existential phase in modern American history that will hopefully draw to an end in the next few days.

And yet this will be an election like no other. For the first time in US history, an incumbent president has consistently refused to promise that should he lose, he will abide by the results of the vote. That has prompted House Speaker Nancy Pelosi to warn that should Donald Trump lose on Election Day and should he refuse to accept the results, he will be fumigated out of the White House. For his part, Joe Biden has noted that the White House is no place for trespassers.

It will be a difficult election, perhaps even bizarre. It has not always been, indeed has never quite beenlike this. And yet there are all the instances of presidential elections in the United States throwing up results that were as unexpected as they were intriguing. To this day, questions have persisted about the 1960 election which pitted Vice President Richard Nixon against Senator John Kennedy. 

Many have believed that Nixon won the election but that a last minute ploy in releasing a bunch of questionable votes for Kennedy by Chicago Mayor Richard Daley reversed the result. Nixon’s advisers toyed with the idea of challenging the outcome. For his part, Nixon was unwilling to set such a bad precedent.

And then of course there is the election of 2000, which definitively showed Vice President Al Gore edging ahead of George W Bush. It was an election where not until mid-December -- long after polling day in November -- did Americans know who would succeed Bill Clinton in the White House. And that result was arrived at per courtesy of the US Supreme Court, which decreed an end to the counting of votes, hanging chads as they were called, in Florida and declared Bush the winner. Research by political analysts was, however, to show that Gore won Florida by 23,000 votes, enough for him to be declared the victor nationwide and take over as America’s new leader.

That takes us back to the year 1876, when the Democratic presidential candidate Samuel Tilden beat Republican Rutherford B Hayes by 264,000 votes and was clearly on his way to the White House. But Hayes and his party challenged the results. The Electoral Commission, appointed by Congress, handed the presidency to Hayes by a single vote. In this instance too a Supreme Court justice played a pivotal role. 

The wrong man thus became president, while Tilden went back to private life. In 1888, the electoral triumph of Grover Cleveland was neutralized by a system that has come to be known as the Electoral College. In 2016, despite getting three million more votes than Donald Trump -- and don’t forget that matter of Russian interference in the election -- Hillary Clinton lost. The Electoral College cheerfully placed the loser in presidential office.

These lapses apart, presidential elections in America have been reflective of popular aspirations, as was noticed through the four elections Franklin Delano Roosevelt won between 1932 and 1944. It was one of those times when presidential terms were not limited to two, but once FDR passed from the scene, the rule was made more disciplined: No president could stay in office for more than two terms. 

But, then, there have been presidents unfortunate enough to lose their bid for a second term, for reasons of a diverse nature. George HW Bush, elected in 1988, went down to defeat at the hands of Bill Clinton in 1992. Gerald Ford, the only man appointed to the presidency in the aftermath of Watergate in 1974, sought a term on his own in 1976, only to be beaten by the peanut farmer and former governor of Georgia Jimmy Carter. Ironically, Carter’s own bid for a second term as president was thwarted by Ronald Reagan in 1980.

Within minutes of President John F Kennedy’s assassination in Dallas in November 1963, Vice President Lyndon Johnson was sworn in as the country’s 36th president abroad Air Force One as it prepared to carry Kennedy’s body back to Washington. Johnson was elected in his own right the following year, defeating the Republican Barry Goldwater in a landslide. And then Vietnam entered the picture, destroying Johnson’s hopes for a second term. When Senator Eugene McCarthy nearly beat him at the New Hampshire primary in early 1968, he decided not to go for a second term. 

One of the more remarkable of presidential stories in America is certainly Richard Nixon’s. After his loss to Kennedy in 1960, he campaigned for the governorship of California against Edmund “Pat” Brown in 1962. He lost the election, at which point he informed the media that they would not have him to kick around anymore because “gentlemen, this is my last press conference.”

But ever the man of ambition, Nixon did not go off into the sunset. At the mid-term elections in 1966, he campaigned vigorously for Republican candidates to the House and the Senate, helping a good number of themto get elected. In 1968, he won the Republican nomination for president a second time and went on to beat Vice President Hubert Humphrey, albeit narrowly, in November. Four years later, Nixon beat George McGovern by a landslide. Watergate destroyed his presidency in August 1974.

In 1948, Harry Truman, who had taken over as president following President Roosevelt’s death in April 1945, was running well behind New York governor Thomas Dewey in his campaign for a term on his own in the White House. Opinion polls consistently predicted a victory for Dewey, but in one of those upsets that have sometimes upended American politics, Truman came back from behind to beat Dewey. He did not seek a second term in 1952, when World War Two fame Dwight Eisenhower defeated Adlai Stevenson at the presidential election. Eisenhower beat Stevenson a second time in 1956.

Hence the many stories of presidential elections in the United States of America. Many too are the tales of men of ambition who struggled, often long and hard, to be president but ended up disappointed. Nelson Rockefeller, Gary Hart, Michael Dukakis, George Romney, Harold Stassen, William Scranton, Walter Mondale, John McCain, Mitt Romney and so many others are today footnotes in the history of races for the White House in our times. 

Syed Badrul Ahsan is a journalist and biographer.