Bernie wins, finally

Bernie Sanders won New Hampshire, but that’s only half the story. While his campaign is taking a well-deserved victory lap the truth of the matter is that four years ago he carried the state by 20 points and this time around he squeaked through by 2 against the former Mayor of the 31th largest city in the United States. 

A win in these early states is supposed to provide momentum and positive media coverage that campaigns use as fuel leading up to super Tuesday, but this result will probably give him neither. The narrative has shifted to the strong showings by Pete Buttigieg and Amy Klobuchar, Joe Biden’s implosion and Elizabeth Warren’s continued slump. What that says about the media and the Democratic party is not up for interpretation. It appears that anyone is a better candidate than the Democratic Socialist from Vermont, but voters seem to have other ideas. 

What makes New Hampshire an interesting ideological training ground is the fact that registered independents can vote in the Democratic primary. A strong showing with those independents can point to a candidate’s strength in turning undecided and even republican voters. Much like four years ago preliminary data says Sanders has over performed with those voters again in New Hampshire. This bodes well for his national campaign and undercuts to so-called electability argument against him. But as he moves into Nevada and South Carolina it seems exceedingly clear that he’s fighting a battle against both this primary opponents and brains trust of the Democratic party.

The biggest surprise out of New Hampshire was Amy Klobuchar. After a strong showing in last week’s debate she seemingly came out of the cold to finish a very strong third, pushing Buttigieg all the way. She savaged him at the debates, calling him a lightweight and has continued to pick apart his albeit flimsy legacy as Mayor of South Bend. In the 12 hours after the polls closed in New Hampshire she also raised an astonishing $2.5 million. All this from a candidate that was begging for airtime and name recognition two weeks ago. Her rise seems to have mirrored Biden’s downward spiral and is probably taking voters away from him. If that is the case, then the battle for the moderate Democratic vote could now be a two-way competition between her and Buttigieg.


Also Read- The comeback kid?


The 38-year-old veteran eventually ended a few points behind Sanders in New Hampshire and while that is an incredible performance, he does not have the time to rest on his laurels just yet. He clearly did better in a matchup with the progressive Sanders than most had imagined but also did much worse against his fellow moderate Klobuchar than anyone expected. And therein lies the tension for his campaign moving forward, should he focus on Sanders or Klobuchar and Biden. His support among non-white voters is almost non-existent and as they move into more ethnically diverse states such as Nevada and South Carolina he will really need to make case as to why moderate democrats should choose him over his competitors.

Joe Biden knew he would tank in New Hampshire, he said so in the debate last week and left the state for South Carolina when voting was still on. His disastrous 5th place finish has put a lot of pressure on him to perform in Nevada where he currently holds a slim advantage in the polls and South Carolina where he leads by a whopping 12 points now. With Klobuchar and Buttigieg eating into this numbers he needs to finish first or second in Nevada if he hopes to have any realistic chance of the getting the democratic nomination. South Carolina is considered his firewall, but he might be all but out of the race by then. Things don’t look good for the former Vice President.

New Hampshire looks to have been the moment that progressive Democrats finally chose to go with Sanders over Elizabeth Warren. Her embarrassing 4th place finish 10 points behind Klobuchar has stopped whatever momentum she had dead in its tracks. She sent out an email after the polls closed to say that she will continue her campaign no matter what and that brings up an interesting situation. 

No democratic primary is a winner takes all situation, if she soldiers on till the very end and winds up with 10 to 15% of the delegates, she could be a hugely influential power broker at the Democratic national convention. It looks like the Democratic party is headed for a contested convention. God helps us all.

Nader Rahman is a freelance journalist based in New York