The comeback kid?

After finishing a close second in New Hampshire in 1992, Bill Clinton famously called himself ‘the comeback kid.’ It really was quite extraordinary, a few weeks earlier he had been accused of having an affair and dodging the draft. Less than two months later he was all but confirmed at the democratic nominee for president, and the rest as they say is history.  

Those might have been simpler times but as the primary moves to New Hampshire today Pete Buttigieg is certainly hoping he can take the stage on Tuesday night and make the same pitch. After having consistently trailed Joe Biden and Elizabeth Warren in the New Hampshire polls, the confusion around Iowa that led to his sneaky declaration as the winner suddenly sent his numbers soaring. He went from fourth to second in the polls and within the statistical margin of error to the frontrunner Bernie Sanders in a few of them. 

Make no mistake about it, this is huge news. In 2016 Sanders won the state by 20 points against Hillary Clinton and even with a crowded field this time around he has held a significant advantage in the polls (most of them by about 10 points) until this week. Buttigieg was always going to get a bump in the polls after Iowa, but to move within striking distance of Sanders who remains hugely popular in the state might be proof that he’s the new centrist choice of the democratic party.

Interestingly in a few new polls the Biden campaign is even behind Amy Klobuchar after her strong performance in last debate. Biden now seems destined for yet another poor finish, this time around in New Hampshire. He narrowly leads the polls in Nevada and is an overwhelming favourite in South Carolina but with two below par performances back-to-back, those numbers could quickly change. For over a year he has been the centrist candidate of choice for the Democratic party, yet with Buttigieg breathing down his neck and Klobuchar making waves as well he might simply be treading water now. 

This should worry Sanders. Having led the polls for months in New Hampshire he now has to face a real contest to win the state. Sanders will also have to factor into account that running as a centrist Buttigieg looks poised to pick up most of the votes Biden loses in the granite state. This should be worrisome for the Sanders campaign in New Hampshire, and Nevada and South Carolina to come.

What Sanders now has to start planning for is how to pick up some of Elizabeth Warren’s supporters as her numbers have remained steady yet unspectacular. That being said Sanders remains hugely popular in New Hampshire and should be able to win with relative ease. But if Buttigieg finishes a close second, that could be hugely embarrassing for the Senator from Vermont and give the former mayor a narrative straight from the Clinton playbook in 1992. Except this time around the comeback kid will actually be just that, a 38-year-old kid. 

Nader Rahman is a freelance journalist based in New York