Three ways Mideast fighting threatens US national security

As fighting in the Middle East continues – from Israel to Iraq – some senior US military officials are acknowledging that they are pessimistic about the prospect for peace in the region. “Is there going to be peace in the Middle East?” Lt. Gen. Michael Flynn, head of the Defense Intelligence Agency (DIA), asked himself aloud last week, before an audience of national security specialists. “Not in my lifetime. Not in my lifetime.”

Pentagon analysts, according to a report by The Christian Science Monitor, are increasingly grappling with what this growing unrest means for US national security. Here are the top three ways the advance of the insurgent group the Islamic State in Iraq and violence in Gaza could endanger US national security.

Hamas could be replaced by a group able to use chemical weapons

If Hamas is destroyed, an even more dangerous group – intent on obtaining biological or chemical weapons – could step in and take its place.

That was the sobering warning from General Flynn. “If Hamas were fully destroyed – and, you know, and gone – we would probably probably end up with something much worse, or the region would end up with something much worse,” he said in remarks at the Aspen Security Forum last week.

This is on the radar screen of the Israeli government as they wage war in Gaza, he added. “I think that they recognize this, you know, better than anybody.” There is, too, the possibility that these groups could procure biological or chemical agents from depots in Syria given the chaos of war there, Flynn added, calling it “one of the most dangerous threats.” 

Despite international efforts to collect and destroy them, “There are still chemical weapons or chemical capabilities in that part of the world,” he said. “And in the hands of people who I know have the intent to use them, we need to be concerned about that.”

The cost of the growing war in Iraq, both in lives lost and US GDP, could be large

It is likely that the current war in Iraq “will probably look much like Syria’s soon, and may in time look a lot like Iraq itself circa 2006,” Stephen Biddle, professor of international affairs at George Washington University and a frequent Pentagon consultant, told the House Armed Services Committee on Tuesday.

In Syria, more than 50,000 civilians have died “with no end in sight,” Dr. Biddle said. In Iraq, more than 120,000 civilians were killed between 2003 and 2011. “A renewed Iraq war of seven to 10 years duration could easily produce another 100,000 innocent lives lost,” he added. “The United States has not often intervened militarily into ongoing civil wars on purely humanitarian grounds, but the scale of potential suffering here is large. And far worse could be in store if Iraq’s war spreads.”

That is a real possibility. Of the 142 civil wars fought between 1950 and 1999, Biddle points out, “fully 61 saw major military intervention by neighboring states at some point.”

If human suffering is not a motivation for US intervention, economic loss may be. While US economic exposure to Gulf oil shocks may be declining as US shale oil and gas develop, still “serious risks will remain for the foreseeable future,” Biddle said. “A serious reduction in Gulf production would be a globally significant economic threat,” with the worst case scenario suggesting that it could exceed the largest previous Gulf oil shock (the 1973-74 OPEC embargo) by a factor of four. “The best available analysis suggests this might double world oil prices, cutting US GDP by 3 to 5 percentage points,” Biddle said. “At 2014 levels, this would imply $450bn to $750bn a year in lost output.”

The US could take its eye off the ball in other parts of the world

As a result of the wars in Iraq and Syria, Iran “is finding itself as a new regional influencer because of all of the things that are going on,” Flynn said, which has, in turn, empowered a country adversarial to the US and committed to pursuing a nuclear program.

In the midst of the Middle East crisis, North Korea, too, continues to pursue nuclear weapons. The dictatorship launched another missile test on Wednesday. “North Korea has been in the process of firing off these missiles,” Flynn said, “and they are essentially desensitizing us because they want to know, or want us to know, that they have this capability.”

This leads to other dangerous problems, Adm. Samuel Locklear, head of US Pacific Command, told Pentagon reporters on Tuesday. “I think the long-term concern with North Korea is that every time they do something that the international community has told them not to do – particularly as it relates to missile technology or nuclear technology – you have to assume that it’s a step forward in technology, otherwise, they probably wouldn’t be doing it.”

“We have to continue to demand that they denuclearize and that they stop their missile program in the fashion they have it today,” he added. “Will they or not? I don’t know.”