Why war on Aleppo is so important
Publish : 09 Oct 2016, 22:19
Russia vetoed a French-drafted United Nations Security Council resolution on Saturday that would have demanded an immediate end to airstrikes and military flights over the Syrian city of Aleppo. It also called for a truce and humanitarian aid access throughout Syria.
It is the fifth time Russia has vetoed a UN resolution on Syria during the more than five-year conflict. The previous four times Moscow was backed by Beijing, but on Saturday China abstained from the vote. The vote in the Security Council on Saturday afternoon was 11 countries in favour, two against and two abstentions.
The Russian Foreign Ministry said on Sunday a draft French UN Security Council resolution on Syria would have helped Islamist militants in the Aleppo area by protecting them from aerial bombing.
In a statement, the ministry also said the French text was politicised and one-sided.
China’s UN Ambassador Liu Jieyi said some of the content of the French draft “does not reflect the full respect for the sovereignty, independence, unification and territorial integrity of Syria,” while the content of the Russian draft did.
Shortly after the Russian veto, the Security Council rejected the rival draft presented by Moscow by a vote of nine against, four in favour and two abstentions.
Britain, France and the United States voted against the Russian measure that called for a ceasefire but did not mention a halt in the air strikes.
Russian Ambassador Vitaly Churkin, who holds the council presidency, said the two votes represented “one of the strangest spectacles” at the Security Council because all 15 members knew from the outset that they would fail.
Here are some of the key questions surrounding the battle for Aleppo:
Why is Aleppo so important in the Syrian war?
Before the war started in 2011, Aleppo was Syria’s most populous city and its economic hub. President Bashar Assad can’t credibly claim to rule Syria without it. Assad has been intending to retake it for years.
For the opposition, it’s the most significant urban area where it has control. While many have fled the area, Eastern Aleppo shows the rebels do have significant grassroots support. It’s a place where the rebels can display how Syria could be without the rule by the Assad family, which has run the country for more than four decades. A local council has provided a semblance governance, service and schools for the past several years.Who’s fighting?
Syria’s military has extensive help. There’s the Russian air force, Lebanon’s Hezbollah militia and assistance from Iran. There are also Shia Muslim militiamen from Afghanistan and Pakistan who are helping the government.
On the rebel side, there are two main operations rooms organizing the defences. They’re mostly Syrian fighters, not foreign, but they represent a mix of ideologies. One of the leading groups was a branch of al-Qaeda until recently and is still seen as its ally. The various factions get support from Arab Gulf countries and Turkey. The US supports what it considers non-extremist groups that seek to remove Assad from power.
The CIA and Saudi Arabia provide weapons, but not as many as rebels have asked for or the anti-aircraft weapons they seek.
One group you won’t find in Aleppo is the Islamic State. That extremist group is based in Raqqa, in eastern Syria. In fact, some of the rebel groups in Aleppo have fought against IS in other areas.Are civilians being targeted in Aleppo?
Yes. Throughout the civil war, the Syrian government army has conducted indiscriminate attacks on civilians. UN investigators have accused it of targeting medical facilities, which have frequently been struck.
The UN says more than 370 civilians — about one-third of them children — have been killed in eastern Aleppo since September 23. There are estimates of perhaps a few dozen civilians being killed in western Aleppo in recent weeks.
The Syrian military has recently attacked the so-called White Helmets, volunteers who rescue victims from rubble. The group receives aid from the US
Rebel forces also strike civilians in government areas. But without an air force, the rebels’ weaponry is smaller and has less reach.
In some towns, the government has followed a pattern of besieging an area, pounding it with air strikes and then offering to let the rebels and civilians flee — basically a surrender of the turf. Such a campaign in Aleppo could take months.Why are so many civilians still in Aleppo?
Millions of Syrians have fled their homes during the five years of fighting, and there’s been a large exodus from Aleppo as well. But the UN says there could still be 2m people in the city.
In eastern Aleppo, perhaps a quarter-million people remain, according to the UN NPR has spoken with people remaining in Aleppo. Some say they fear the regime will take their homes if they leave.
Many are too poor and have no place else to go, except tent shelters near the Turkish border, which is now often closed. Some say they stay because they believe they are helping their neighbours and resisting the Assad regime.What is the US doing — and not doing?
In Syria, the US has been focused on IS, launching thousands of air strikes on the group that’s conducted terror attacks in the West. There are hundreds of US troops in northern Syria, aiding local militias in their fight to take ground from IS. But, again, IS isn’t a factor in the city of Aleppo.
Washington also provides aid to refugees and humanitarian relief for Syrians — around $6bn so far, according to the State Department. The US Agency for International Development says it’s the world’s largest donor to White Helmet rescue teams, giving them at least $23m in assistance so far.
Rebels in Aleppo say they get some aid from intelligence agencies in the US and Saudi Arabia, but complain it’s not nearly enough. They say they recently received some ground-to-ground rockets, but haven’t received anti-aircraft weapons to defend against air strikes. US officials worry anti-aircraft weapons could fall into the hands of extremists, who could use them elsewhere.
The New York Times reported that last month, Secretary of State Kerry told opposition representatives that arming the rebels more would just add fuel to the violence: “Russia puts in more. Iran puts in more,” he said.
The US has tried to negotiate with Russia for a ceasefire in Aleppo, but those talks collapsed. Some have called for no-fly zones or safe zones near Aleppo. Kerry stepped up his rhetoric on Friday, saying, “Russia and the regime owe the world more than an explanation about why they keep hitting hospitals and medical facilities and children and women. These are acts that beg for an appropriate investigation of war crimes. ... They’re beyond the accidental now – way beyond.”Sources: CBC, NPR